1
00:00:00,464 --> 00:00:00,895
龙树

2
00:00:01,264 --> 00:00:03,314
把空推到极限的人

3
00:00:03,664 --> 00:00:05,035
上一期我们聊过

4
00:00:05,104 --> 00:00:06,634
金刚经 像一把刀

5
00:00:06,823 --> 00:00:08,554
指明了什么该砍掉

6
00:00:08,743 --> 00:00:10,414
却没回答一个更根本的问题

7
00:00:11,064 --> 00:00:12,494
凭什么一切都能砍

8
00:00:13,103 --> 00:00:13,814
砍完之后

9
00:00:14,144 --> 00:00:14,974
还剩下什么

10
00:00:15,790 --> 00:00:17,241
今天要讲的这个人

11
00:00:17,270 --> 00:00:19,041
不满足于仅仅挥刀

12
00:00:19,471 --> 00:00:21,230
他要从逻辑上证明

13
00:00:21,230 --> 00:00:23,802
这世上本就没有砍不掉的东西

14
00:00:24,351 --> 00:00:25,561
他叫龙树

15
00:00:25,823 --> 00:00:26,173
哈喽

16
00:00:26,222 --> 00:00:26,693
大家好

17
00:00:26,862 --> 00:00:27,914
我是王利杰

18
00:00:28,183 --> 00:00:30,914
这个系列从佛陀讲到般若经

19
00:00:30,943 --> 00:00:33,634
又讲到 金刚经 在中国的逆袭

20
00:00:33,982 --> 00:00:34,374
现在

21
00:00:34,743 --> 00:00:36,554
时间线要拉回印度

22
00:00:36,649 --> 00:00:38,260
公元二至三世纪

23
00:00:38,329 --> 00:00:41,180
佛教正面临一场深重的思想危机

24
00:00:41,488 --> 00:00:42,400
龙树的出现

25
00:00:42,729 --> 00:00:44,739
彻底扭转了危机的走向

26
00:00:44,969 --> 00:00:47,699
今天只谈龙树其人 他的时代

27
00:00:47,769 --> 00:00:50,140
以及他身处的那场思想战争

28
00:00:50,488 --> 00:00:53,820
至于他如何回应对手最致命的那一记反诘

29
00:00:54,168 --> 00:00:56,500
以及这个回答引发的新难题

30
00:00:56,528 --> 00:00:57,699
留给下一期

31
00:00:58,345 --> 00:01:00,117
先看他登场前的印度

32
00:01:00,345 --> 00:01:02,236
公元二世纪前后的印度

33
00:01:02,306 --> 00:01:05,157
思想市场的竞争远比想象中激烈

34
00:01:05,466 --> 00:01:07,276
佛教并非唯一的主角

35
00:01:07,626 --> 00:01:09,317
婆罗门教正在复兴

36
00:01:09,466 --> 00:01:13,936
奥义书传统的哲学家用日益精密的逻辑论证梵我合一

37
00:01:14,546 --> 00:01:18,056
正理派正在建立一套专为辩论打造的逻辑体系

38
00:01:18,705 --> 00:01:21,037
耆那教也有自己的一套世界观

39
00:01:21,466 --> 00:01:22,745
在这个擂台上

40
00:01:22,746 --> 00:01:25,677
每个学派都必须亮出最锋利的武器

41
00:01:25,705 --> 00:01:28,317
否则就会被对手的逻辑碾碎

42
00:01:28,754 --> 00:01:30,366
佛教内部也不太平

43
00:01:30,554 --> 00:01:32,685
之前讲说一切有部时提过

44
00:01:32,795 --> 00:01:34,006
佛陀入灭后

45
00:01:34,034 --> 00:01:36,666
僧团里最聪明的一批人开始做一件事

46
00:01:37,155 --> 00:01:40,166
把佛陀讲的道理拆解成最小的零件

47
00:01:40,354 --> 00:01:42,926
就像物理学家寻找基本粒子一样

48
00:01:42,994 --> 00:01:46,634
他们把佛法拆成了七十五种最基本的存在单元

49
00:01:46,634 --> 00:01:47,485
称为法

50
00:01:47,744 --> 00:01:50,074
这套分析体系精密得惊人

51
00:01:50,384 --> 00:01:51,054
心是什么

52
00:01:51,303 --> 00:01:52,223
色是什么

53
00:01:52,223 --> 00:01:53,875
不相应行法是什么

54
00:01:53,904 --> 00:01:57,354
每一种都有定义 边界和运作规则

55
00:01:57,583 --> 00:02:00,675
你可以把它想象成一张巨大的元素周期表

56
00:02:00,744 --> 00:02:02,583
排列的不是化学元素

57
00:02:02,583 --> 00:02:05,194
而是构成一切经验的最基本成分

58
00:02:05,687 --> 00:02:07,958
这种精密分析有个巨大优势

59
00:02:08,448 --> 00:02:09,659
面对外道时

60
00:02:09,728 --> 00:02:11,458
它能扛住逻辑攻击

61
00:02:11,607 --> 00:02:13,718
你说佛教讲空 什么都没有

62
00:02:14,087 --> 00:02:14,438
不对

63
00:02:14,887 --> 00:02:16,539
这里有七十五种法

64
00:02:16,607 --> 00:02:18,159
每种都定义清晰

65
00:02:18,487 --> 00:02:19,859
你来反驳试试

66
00:02:20,248 --> 00:02:25,139
这套体系让佛教在思想竞争中获得了极强的防御力

67
00:02:25,427 --> 00:02:27,106
但防御是有代价的

68
00:02:27,106 --> 00:02:28,917
甚至藏着致命隐患

69
00:02:29,427 --> 00:02:30,905
说一切有部认为

70
00:02:30,906 --> 00:02:33,237
这七十五种法各有自性

71
00:02:33,506 --> 00:02:34,426
所谓自性

72
00:02:34,427 --> 00:02:37,598
就是独立 不依赖他物而成立的本质

73
00:02:37,974 --> 00:02:38,726
问题出在哪

74
00:02:39,254 --> 00:02:42,205
佛陀在菩提树下证悟的核心是缘起

75
00:02:42,694 --> 00:02:44,946
万物皆因缘和合而生

76
00:02:45,055 --> 00:02:46,825
无一物可独立存在

77
00:02:46,894 --> 00:02:48,346
这是佛法的地基

78
00:02:48,740 --> 00:02:50,790
可有部在分析佛法时

79
00:02:50,860 --> 00:02:53,910
却给分析工具本身赋予了独立自性

80
00:02:54,179 --> 00:02:56,470
他们用缘起的框架解释世界

81
00:02:56,499 --> 00:02:58,259
可构成框架的砖头

82
00:02:58,260 --> 00:02:59,871
恰恰违背了缘起

83
00:03:00,179 --> 00:03:03,579
这就好比一个人宣称世上没有永恒不变之物

84
00:03:03,580 --> 00:03:06,350
转头却拿出一块刻着这句话的石碑

85
00:03:06,379 --> 00:03:08,230
说这块石碑永恒不变

86
00:03:08,853 --> 00:03:10,664
到了公元二世纪前后

87
00:03:10,732 --> 00:03:12,784
矛盾已积累至临界点

88
00:03:13,172 --> 00:03:13,963
不只是有部

89
00:03:14,332 --> 00:03:16,083
其他部派也各有各的病

90
00:03:16,693 --> 00:03:18,604
有的把空性理解成虚无

91
00:03:18,973 --> 00:03:19,843
索性躺平

92
00:03:20,413 --> 00:03:23,183
有的把佛法变成纯粹的学术体操

93
00:03:23,373 --> 00:03:24,863
概念越发精密

94
00:03:24,892 --> 00:03:26,743
离修行却越来越远

95
00:03:27,172 --> 00:03:28,284
佛教需要一个人

96
00:03:28,612 --> 00:03:30,143
重新清理地基

97
00:03:31,148 --> 00:03:32,600
这个人就是龙树

98
00:03:32,868 --> 00:03:34,019
关于龙树的生平

99
00:03:34,349 --> 00:03:36,160
确切事实其实很少

100
00:03:36,349 --> 00:03:39,920
他大约生活在公元二世纪中叶至三世纪初

101
00:03:40,189 --> 00:03:41,868
主要活动于南印度

102
00:03:41,868 --> 00:03:43,679
即今天的安得拉邦一带

103
00:03:43,988 --> 00:03:45,868
学者之所以能确认这点

104
00:03:45,868 --> 00:03:47,299
是因为他写过两封信

105
00:03:47,668 --> 00:03:49,700
亲友书 和 宝行王正论

106
00:03:50,229 --> 00:03:54,360
收信人是案达罗地区娑多婆诃王朝的一位国王

107
00:03:54,588 --> 00:03:58,279
这是龙树与真实历史之间最硬的一条线索

108
00:03:58,827 --> 00:04:01,439
但你大概听过更富戏剧性的传说

109
00:04:01,628 --> 00:04:04,106
据说他年少时聪慧绝顶

110
00:04:04,107 --> 00:04:06,066
与三个朋友学了隐身术

111
00:04:06,067 --> 00:04:08,078
溜进王宫偷看宫女

112
00:04:08,387 --> 00:04:10,719
事败后三个朋友当场被杀

113
00:04:10,827 --> 00:04:13,918
唯有他紧贴国王身后才侥幸逃生

114
00:04:14,148 --> 00:04:15,838
此事令他大受震动

115
00:04:15,868 --> 00:04:18,107
觉悟到欲望乃痛苦之源

116
00:04:18,107 --> 00:04:19,119
于是出家

117
00:04:19,517 --> 00:04:21,808
还有一个更广为人知的故事

118
00:04:22,077 --> 00:04:23,248
说他出家后

119
00:04:23,318 --> 00:04:26,089
在人间经典中找不到满意的答案

120
00:04:26,157 --> 00:04:28,729
便有龙王将他带入海底龙宫

121
00:04:28,918 --> 00:04:31,969
龙宫里藏着大乘般若经的完整版

122
00:04:32,197 --> 00:04:34,236
龙树从中取出经典

123
00:04:34,238 --> 00:04:35,289
带回人间

124
00:04:35,678 --> 00:04:36,769
信不信由你

125
00:04:36,998 --> 00:04:38,508
但这至少解释了一件事

126
00:04:38,957 --> 00:04:41,209
为何他的名字里有个龙字

127
00:04:41,619 --> 00:04:42,949
不过学者提醒

128
00:04:43,059 --> 00:04:46,737
这些传说均出自他去世数百年后的传记

129
00:04:46,739 --> 00:04:47,869
并非信史

130
00:04:48,138 --> 00:04:49,670
关于他的真实人生

131
00:04:49,698 --> 00:04:51,290
我们能确认的只有三点

132
00:04:51,698 --> 00:04:51,889
一

133
00:04:52,259 --> 00:04:54,809
生活在公元二至三世纪的南印度

134
00:04:55,179 --> 00:04:55,369
二

135
00:04:55,698 --> 00:04:57,569
与一位国王有书信往来

136
00:04:57,869 --> 00:04:58,658
三

137
00:04:58,658 --> 00:05:03,230
写下了一批在佛教思想史上具有地震级影响力的著作

138
00:05:03,458 --> 00:05:05,150
其余皆是传说

139
00:05:05,453 --> 00:05:06,371
有趣的是

140
00:05:06,373 --> 00:05:09,864
龙树给国王的那两封信语气颇为私人

141
00:05:10,253 --> 00:05:14,224
亲友书 里有段话劝国王少喝酒 管住脾气

142
00:05:14,398 --> 00:05:15,172
试想

143
00:05:15,172 --> 00:05:18,823
一位佛教哲学家致信当时最有权势的人之一

144
00:05:18,893 --> 00:05:20,292
不谈国事政治

145
00:05:20,292 --> 00:05:22,343
倒像老朋友般叮嘱一句

146
00:05:22,412 --> 00:05:23,604
最近酒喝多了吧

147
00:05:23,852 --> 00:05:24,624
悠着点

148
00:05:24,813 --> 00:05:26,371
这个细节让人觉得

149
00:05:26,373 --> 00:05:29,023
龙树不是活在书斋里的纯理论家

150
00:05:29,172 --> 00:05:31,744
他与真实世界有着很深的连接

151
00:05:32,579 --> 00:05:35,110
但传说往往不是凭空捏造

152
00:05:35,259 --> 00:05:39,350
通常是后人用故事来解释某个无法理解的事实

153
00:05:39,860 --> 00:05:41,370
龙树的事实是什么

154
00:05:41,939 --> 00:05:43,538
一个人仅凭逻辑

155
00:05:43,540 --> 00:05:46,910
就把整个佛教哲学的地基翻新了一遍

156
00:05:47,179 --> 00:05:49,670
后人无法解释这种智力的爆发

157
00:05:49,699 --> 00:05:53,098
便编出龙宫取经的故事 意思是

158
00:05:53,100 --> 00:05:55,511
这种智慧不可能属于人间

159
00:05:55,660 --> 00:05:59,030
定是从某个超越凡俗的地方带回来的

160
00:05:59,905 --> 00:06:00,984
传说讲完了

161
00:06:00,986 --> 00:06:04,037
来看龙树面对的那场真正的思想战争

162
00:06:04,306 --> 00:06:05,237
在他之前

163
00:06:05,345 --> 00:06:08,556
说一切有部是影响力最大的佛教学派之一

164
00:06:08,785 --> 00:06:11,104
其阿毗达摩体系精密系统

165
00:06:11,105 --> 00:06:14,556
是整个佛教世界最成熟的哲学分析工具

166
00:06:15,357 --> 00:06:17,636
但龙树看到的不是精密

167
00:06:17,638 --> 00:06:19,729
而是地基上的一道裂缝

168
00:06:20,078 --> 00:06:21,929
裂缝就是自性

169
00:06:22,318 --> 00:06:22,908
打个比方

170
00:06:23,278 --> 00:06:26,049
有位建筑师设计了一栋漂亮的大楼

171
00:06:26,117 --> 00:06:28,436
每层结构都经过精密计算

172
00:06:28,438 --> 00:06:30,369
每面墙都严丝合缝

173
00:06:30,557 --> 00:06:31,508
龙树走过去

174
00:06:31,677 --> 00:06:32,756
不看楼上

175
00:06:32,758 --> 00:06:34,189
只蹲下来看地基

176
00:06:34,438 --> 00:06:34,948
然后说

177
00:06:35,318 --> 00:06:37,196
你这栋楼地基用的材料

178
00:06:37,198 --> 00:06:39,129
和你声称要防范的东西

179
00:06:39,198 --> 00:06:40,528
是同一种东西

180
00:06:41,669 --> 00:06:44,599
有部声称万物缘起 无常 无我

181
00:06:44,669 --> 00:06:47,559
但他们用来分析缘起的七十五种法

182
00:06:47,589 --> 00:06:50,719
却被赋予了自性 即独立不变的本质

183
00:06:50,909 --> 00:06:52,907
一边说世上没有永恒之物

184
00:06:52,909 --> 00:06:55,679
一边又说自己的分析工具永恒不变

185
00:06:55,789 --> 00:06:57,440
这在逻辑上说不通

186
00:06:57,669 --> 00:06:59,719
龙树抓住的正是这一点

187
00:07:00,504 --> 00:07:02,016
他的方法极为独特

188
00:07:02,425 --> 00:07:03,824
不提任何主张

189
00:07:03,824 --> 00:07:04,896
不说世界如何

190
00:07:05,144 --> 00:07:06,595
不说真理何在

191
00:07:06,824 --> 00:07:07,936
他只做一个动作

192
00:07:08,345 --> 00:07:09,956
接过对方的主张

193
00:07:09,985 --> 00:07:12,675
顺着对方自己的逻辑往下推

194
00:07:12,785 --> 00:07:13,576
推到尽头

195
00:07:13,824 --> 00:07:15,956
让那逻辑自行崩塌

196
00:07:16,064 --> 00:07:17,636
这叫归谬法

197
00:07:18,025 --> 00:07:19,424
不必记这个名字

198
00:07:19,425 --> 00:07:21,744
只需知道龙树不建房子

199
00:07:21,744 --> 00:07:22,956
只拆房子

200
00:07:23,025 --> 00:07:25,076
但他拆房不用锤子砸

201
00:07:25,105 --> 00:07:28,103
而是证明你的房子是用矛盾砌成的

202
00:07:28,105 --> 00:07:29,276
它自己会塌

203
00:07:30,305 --> 00:07:31,304
在 中论 里

204
00:07:31,305 --> 00:07:34,357
他把有部的核心概念逐一拿出来检验

205
00:07:34,586 --> 00:07:35,557
比如生灭

206
00:07:35,706 --> 00:07:37,417
有部说法从因缘生

207
00:07:37,665 --> 00:07:39,076
又在因缘中灭

208
00:07:39,220 --> 00:07:39,811
龙树问

209
00:07:40,259 --> 00:07:41,831
若一物有自性

210
00:07:41,939 --> 00:07:43,470
它便不可能生起

211
00:07:43,580 --> 00:07:44,811
因为它已然存在

212
00:07:45,220 --> 00:07:46,050
何须再生

213
00:07:46,619 --> 00:07:47,410
若无自性

214
00:07:47,699 --> 00:07:49,071
也不可能生起

215
00:07:49,259 --> 00:07:50,650
一个本不存在的东西

216
00:07:51,100 --> 00:07:51,970
拿什么来生

217
00:07:52,660 --> 00:07:53,931
你说它从因缘生

218
00:07:54,340 --> 00:07:56,030
可若因缘也有自性

219
00:07:56,059 --> 00:07:59,030
那因缘本身就不需要其他因缘来产生

220
00:07:59,140 --> 00:08:00,331
这就不是缘起了

221
00:08:00,859 --> 00:08:02,350
若因缘无自性

222
00:08:02,379 --> 00:08:06,311
那就是一个无自性之物产生了另一个无自性之物

223
00:08:06,420 --> 00:08:07,691
那么这个产生本身

224
00:08:08,059 --> 00:08:08,811
有没有自性

225
00:08:09,580 --> 00:08:09,931
你看

226
00:08:10,420 --> 00:08:12,110
顺着这条线走下去

227
00:08:12,140 --> 00:08:13,790
每一步都走不通

228
00:08:14,554 --> 00:08:17,765
对运动 时间 因果 感知

229
00:08:17,794 --> 00:08:19,606
龙树都做了同样的分析

230
00:08:19,755 --> 00:08:20,905
结论始终如一

231
00:08:21,395 --> 00:08:23,885
只要给任何一个概念赋予自性

232
00:08:23,914 --> 00:08:26,005
认定它有独立不依的本质

233
00:08:26,034 --> 00:08:27,385
它就无法参与缘起

234
00:08:27,835 --> 00:08:29,073
而不参与缘起

235
00:08:29,075 --> 00:08:31,205
就不是佛陀所说的任何东西

236
00:08:31,635 --> 00:08:32,066
这一刀

237
00:08:32,354 --> 00:08:34,405
砍到了佛教哲学的骨头上

238
00:08:34,824 --> 00:08:37,155
而且他不只对内部动手

239
00:08:37,263 --> 00:08:39,543
他写 回诤论 回应质疑者

240
00:08:39,544 --> 00:08:43,714
又写 广破论 将矛头指向佛教之外的正理派

241
00:08:43,904 --> 00:08:47,234
正理派是当时印度最擅长逻辑的学派

242
00:08:47,343 --> 00:08:49,675
有一套成型的认识论体系

243
00:08:49,743 --> 00:08:53,035
定义了何为正确认知 何为有效推理

244
00:08:53,184 --> 00:08:54,214
龙树走进去

245
00:08:54,503 --> 00:08:56,103
用他们自己的规则

246
00:08:56,103 --> 00:08:58,875
证明其认识论基础同样站不住脚

247
00:08:59,144 --> 00:09:02,114
可以想见当时印度思想界的震动

248
00:09:02,944 --> 00:09:06,035
一个人同时挑战了佛教内部最大的学派

249
00:09:06,064 --> 00:09:08,194
和外道最强的逻辑学派

250
00:09:08,463 --> 00:09:11,035
辩论时不拿权威和经典压人

251
00:09:11,184 --> 00:09:12,214
只靠一条规则

252
00:09:12,664 --> 00:09:13,535
你自己说的话

253
00:09:13,824 --> 00:09:15,015
自己能不能站得住

254
00:09:15,784 --> 00:09:16,454
但请注意

255
00:09:16,784 --> 00:09:19,234
龙树砍的不是佛陀的教法

256
00:09:19,343 --> 00:09:22,434
而是后人给教法加上去的那层东西

257
00:09:22,863 --> 00:09:24,795
有部在分析佛法时

258
00:09:24,824 --> 00:09:29,314
不知不觉给框架本身赋予了佛陀从未赋予的属性

259
00:09:29,544 --> 00:09:30,535
龙树所做的

260
00:09:30,784 --> 00:09:32,622
是清理这层附加物

261
00:09:32,623 --> 00:09:35,915
让佛陀原始的缘起洞见重新显露

262
00:09:36,364 --> 00:09:38,494
所以他的立场不是虚无主义

263
00:09:38,563 --> 00:09:40,374
他不是说什么都没有

264
00:09:40,443 --> 00:09:43,374
而是说你以为存在的那个独立自性

265
00:09:43,484 --> 00:09:44,695
从来就不存在

266
00:09:45,204 --> 00:09:46,435
事物依然在运作

267
00:09:46,803 --> 00:09:48,294
因果依然成立

268
00:09:48,323 --> 00:09:49,815
修行依然有效

269
00:09:50,043 --> 00:09:51,802
只不过它们运作的方式

270
00:09:51,803 --> 00:09:55,335
不是因为背后有什么永恒不变的零件在支撑

271
00:09:55,523 --> 00:09:58,615
而是因为它们本就是一张互相依存的网

272
00:09:59,004 --> 00:10:02,215
没有任何节点可以脱离这张网独立存在

273
00:10:03,187 --> 00:10:04,119
这就是空

274
00:10:04,467 --> 00:10:05,499
空不是虚无

275
00:10:05,867 --> 00:10:07,078
是没有自性

276
00:10:07,388 --> 00:10:09,479
空是缘起的另一个名字

277
00:10:09,851 --> 00:10:10,922
每每念及此处

278
00:10:11,091 --> 00:10:12,623
都觉得不可思议

279
00:10:12,931 --> 00:10:15,263
一个生活在近两千年前的人

280
00:10:15,331 --> 00:10:17,983
在没有现代逻辑学训练的情况下

281
00:10:18,051 --> 00:10:19,182
仅凭思辨

282
00:10:19,331 --> 00:10:23,623
就提前解决了后来哲学家花了几百年才摸到边的问题

283
00:10:24,211 --> 00:10:25,422
维特根斯坦说

284
00:10:25,652 --> 00:10:28,243
我的语言的界限就是我的世界的界限

285
00:10:28,931 --> 00:10:29,603
德里达说

286
00:10:29,971 --> 00:10:32,103
意义总在延异中滑动

287
00:10:32,451 --> 00:10:35,263
这两位是二十世纪顶尖的思想家

288
00:10:35,451 --> 00:10:37,811
而龙树早了他们一千七百年

289
00:10:37,811 --> 00:10:38,522
就已证明

290
00:10:38,971 --> 00:10:41,011
任何用语言构建的立场

291
00:10:41,012 --> 00:10:43,503
都无法自洽地描述实相

292
00:10:44,007 --> 00:10:46,698
但他的方法也制造了一个新问题

293
00:10:47,166 --> 00:10:49,458
如果龙树不提任何主张

294
00:10:49,647 --> 00:10:52,366
只拆别人的房子而不建自己的

295
00:10:52,367 --> 00:10:53,397
那他站在哪里

296
00:10:53,887 --> 00:10:56,246
他用来拆房的那把逻辑之刀

297
00:10:56,247 --> 00:10:57,718
本身有没有自性

298
00:10:58,247 --> 00:10:58,677
若有

299
00:10:58,967 --> 00:11:00,557
他自己也违背了缘起

300
00:11:00,972 --> 00:11:01,772
若无

301
00:11:01,847 --> 00:11:05,838
他又凭什么用一把没有自性的刀去拆别人的房子

302
00:11:07,015 --> 00:11:07,445
这个问题

303
00:11:07,934 --> 00:11:10,065
是对手当面质问他的

304
00:11:10,334 --> 00:11:11,705
而龙树的回答

305
00:11:11,734 --> 00:11:15,705
是中观哲学最精彩 也最令人困惑的部分

306
00:11:16,015 --> 00:11:16,565
下一期

307
00:11:16,895 --> 00:11:18,986
我们来看龙树如何作答

308
00:11:19,094 --> 00:11:23,346
以及这个回答又如何制造了更大的哲学难题

309
00:11:23,454 --> 00:11:26,626
逼出了一两百年后唯识学派的诞生

310
00:11:26,702 --> 00:11:28,053
你有没有过这样的时刻

311
00:11:28,302 --> 00:11:30,474
以为自己站在坚实的立场上

312
00:11:30,542 --> 00:11:33,033
结果有人顺着你的逻辑往下推

313
00:11:33,143 --> 00:11:35,133
你才发现脚下其实是空的

314
00:11:35,582 --> 00:11:37,714
欢迎在评论区分享你的故事

315
00:11:37,743 --> 00:11:38,413
我是王利杰

316
00:11:38,582 --> 00:11:39,555
我们下期见