1
00:00:00,265 --> 00:00:01,614
你每做一件好事

2
00:00:01,945 --> 00:00:03,834
大脑都在偷偷记账

3
00:00:04,322 --> 00:00:05,572
一千五百年前

4
00:00:05,643 --> 00:00:08,292
有个人把这笔账递到了达摩面前

5
00:00:08,483 --> 00:00:10,491
这个人是梁武帝萧衍

6
00:00:10,522 --> 00:00:12,651
南朝最有权力的男人

7
00:00:12,843 --> 00:00:14,881
他这辈子建了大量寺庙

8
00:00:14,882 --> 00:00:16,572
供养了十几万僧人

9
00:00:16,682 --> 00:00:20,612
亲自抄经 亲自讲法 还四次舍身出家

10
00:00:20,842 --> 00:00:22,121
在当时的中国

11
00:00:22,122 --> 00:00:25,092
没有任何一个人比他对佛教的贡献更大

12
00:00:25,403 --> 00:00:29,491
所以当达摩从印度远渡重洋来到南京的时候

13
00:00:29,682 --> 00:00:31,892
梁武帝迫不及待地问了一个问题

14
00:00:32,163 --> 00:00:33,271
朕做了这么多事

15
00:00:33,603 --> 00:00:34,712
功德有多大

16
00:00:35,554 --> 00:00:36,662
达摩看了他一眼

17
00:00:36,873 --> 00:00:38,003
回了四个字

18
00:00:38,153 --> 00:00:39,363
并无功德

19
00:00:39,650 --> 00:00:42,379
这段对话记载在禅宗的灯录里

20
00:00:42,449 --> 00:00:44,329
它到底是不是真实的历史

21
00:00:44,330 --> 00:00:45,538
学界有争议

22
00:00:45,690 --> 00:00:48,339
但禅宗把这个故事传了一千多年

23
00:00:48,409 --> 00:00:49,979
不是因为它是历史

24
00:00:50,010 --> 00:00:51,818
而是因为它切中了一个

25
00:00:51,849 --> 00:00:54,619
所有修行者都绕不开的结构性问题

26
00:00:55,150 --> 00:00:55,459
哈喽

27
00:00:55,870 --> 00:00:56,298
大家好

28
00:00:56,790 --> 00:00:57,879
我是王利杰

29
00:00:58,190 --> 00:01:01,318
今天我们来聊聊达摩这四个字背后

30
00:01:01,349 --> 00:01:02,758
到底指向什么

31
00:01:02,950 --> 00:01:05,829
它指向的是佛学里一个极其精密

32
00:01:05,829 --> 00:01:07,719
也极其反直觉的概念

33
00:01:07,790 --> 00:01:09,599
叫做三轮体空

34
00:01:10,123 --> 00:01:10,511
三轮

35
00:01:10,843 --> 00:01:13,212
是指任何善行中的三个角色

36
00:01:13,722 --> 00:01:14,111
施者

37
00:01:14,403 --> 00:01:15,731
就是做好事的人

38
00:01:16,203 --> 00:01:16,632
受者

39
00:01:16,923 --> 00:01:18,451
就是接受善行的人

40
00:01:18,882 --> 00:01:19,671
所施之物

41
00:01:19,963 --> 00:01:21,332
就是善行本身

42
00:01:21,847 --> 00:01:22,647
体空

43
00:01:22,802 --> 00:01:26,091
是说这三个角色都没有独立不变的自性

44
00:01:26,642 --> 00:01:27,511
合起来就是

45
00:01:28,002 --> 00:01:29,171
做善事的你

46
00:01:29,203 --> 00:01:30,432
接受善行的对方

47
00:01:30,763 --> 00:01:32,171
以及善行本身

48
00:01:32,362 --> 00:01:33,111
这三样东西

49
00:01:33,563 --> 00:01:35,332
没有一样是实心的

50
00:01:35,743 --> 00:01:37,593
听到这里你可能觉得

51
00:01:37,704 --> 00:01:40,733
这不就是做好事不图回报换了个说法吗

52
00:01:41,147 --> 00:01:41,948
不是

53
00:01:42,383 --> 00:01:43,352
差远了

54
00:01:43,664 --> 00:01:45,313
做好事不图回报

55
00:01:45,343 --> 00:01:47,632
预设了三样东西是实心的

56
00:01:47,823 --> 00:01:50,513
有一个实实在在的我在做好事

57
00:01:50,623 --> 00:01:53,673
有一个实实在在的对方在接受帮助

58
00:01:53,823 --> 00:01:56,673
有一件实实在在的好事被完成了

59
00:01:56,864 --> 00:01:59,272
只不过我选择不要回报而已

60
00:01:59,504 --> 00:02:00,013
你注意

61
00:02:00,543 --> 00:02:01,492
在这个结构里

62
00:02:01,823 --> 00:02:03,142
我是实心的

63
00:02:03,144 --> 00:02:04,293
对方是实心的

64
00:02:04,584 --> 00:02:06,192
好事是实心的

65
00:02:06,424 --> 00:02:08,432
唯一被拿走的是回报

66
00:02:08,663 --> 00:02:11,073
这还是四个轮子里卸了一个

67
00:02:11,104 --> 00:02:12,992
车本身纹丝没动

68
00:02:13,623 --> 00:02:15,103
三轮体空要做的

69
00:02:15,104 --> 00:02:17,112
不是卸掉回报这个轮子

70
00:02:17,223 --> 00:02:18,552
而是让你看见

71
00:02:18,584 --> 00:02:21,552
这辆车从头到尾就是一个幻觉

72
00:02:22,166 --> 00:02:24,896
我先说一个你每天都在经历的事情

73
00:02:25,166 --> 00:02:27,615
你帮同事处理了一份棘手的文件

74
00:02:27,767 --> 00:02:28,576
搞定了

75
00:02:28,767 --> 00:02:30,115
然后你心里发生了什么

76
00:02:30,607 --> 00:02:33,935
你可能不会跑到同事面前说你欠我一个人情

77
00:02:34,126 --> 00:02:36,435
但你心底有没有冒出一个微妙的感觉

78
00:02:36,927 --> 00:02:38,356
一个我帮了他的感觉

79
00:02:38,886 --> 00:02:41,375
也许这个感觉只持续了半秒钟

80
00:02:41,446 --> 00:02:42,987
但它确实发生了

81
00:02:43,259 --> 00:02:44,147
再想想

82
00:02:44,218 --> 00:02:45,788
你给父母转了一笔钱

83
00:02:45,898 --> 00:02:48,307
你当然不会说我多孝顺啊

84
00:02:48,379 --> 00:02:50,807
但心里有没有一丝温暖的自我确认

85
00:02:51,299 --> 00:02:53,538
有没有一个我是个好儿子

86
00:02:53,539 --> 00:02:55,807
或者我是个好女儿的念头闪过

87
00:02:56,618 --> 00:02:58,267
再想想更微妙的

88
00:02:58,338 --> 00:03:00,468
你在网上看到一个求助帖

89
00:03:00,618 --> 00:03:01,628
捐了一笔款

90
00:03:01,938 --> 00:03:02,607
捐完之后

91
00:03:02,898 --> 00:03:04,728
有没有一瞬间的自我感动

92
00:03:05,259 --> 00:03:08,767
有没有一丝我是一个善良的人的内心独白

93
00:03:09,876 --> 00:03:11,844
这些念头都太快了

94
00:03:11,876 --> 00:03:13,645
快到你几乎意识不到

95
00:03:14,075 --> 00:03:16,125
但它们都指向同一件事

96
00:03:16,556 --> 00:03:18,205
你做的每一件好事

97
00:03:18,235 --> 00:03:20,245
你的大脑都在偷偷记账

98
00:03:20,836 --> 00:03:23,245
而且这本账不只记好事

99
00:03:23,836 --> 00:03:26,634
你今天加班帮公司救了一个项目

100
00:03:26,635 --> 00:03:27,484
你会记

101
00:03:27,876 --> 00:03:30,844
你朋友圈里发了一张自己做志愿者的照片

102
00:03:30,915 --> 00:03:31,884
你也会记

103
00:03:32,395 --> 00:03:34,645
甚至你忍住了没发脾气

104
00:03:34,716 --> 00:03:37,125
你心里都会默默表扬自己一下

105
00:03:37,195 --> 00:03:39,205
今天我情绪管理做得不错

106
00:03:39,876 --> 00:03:41,764
你以为你在修炼品格

107
00:03:41,955 --> 00:03:45,484
其实你在给自我画像一笔一笔地上色

108
00:03:46,036 --> 00:03:47,724
这不是你的品格有问题

109
00:03:48,075 --> 00:03:49,925
这是大脑的出厂设置

110
00:03:51,100 --> 00:03:52,708
认知神经科学发现

111
00:03:52,779 --> 00:03:56,148
人类大脑里有一个叫默认模式网络的系统

112
00:03:56,540 --> 00:04:00,509
这个系统在你不做任何具体任务的时候会自动运转

113
00:04:00,659 --> 00:04:04,268
它干的核心工作就是建构和维护我这个叙事

114
00:04:04,820 --> 00:04:05,289
你是谁

115
00:04:05,659 --> 00:04:06,449
你做过什么

116
00:04:06,659 --> 00:04:07,858
别人怎么看你

117
00:04:07,860 --> 00:04:09,009
你的过去怎么样

118
00:04:09,219 --> 00:04:10,789
你的未来会怎么样

119
00:04:11,179 --> 00:04:15,548
所有这些碎片被默认模式网络编织成一个连贯的故事

120
00:04:15,700 --> 00:04:17,628
这个故事的主角就是我

121
00:04:18,180 --> 00:04:19,659
当你做了一件善事

122
00:04:19,659 --> 00:04:21,579
默认模式网络不会闲着

123
00:04:21,580 --> 00:04:24,669
它会自动把这件善事收编进我的故事里

124
00:04:25,419 --> 00:04:26,818
你做了一件好事

125
00:04:26,820 --> 00:04:29,789
等于你的人生叙事多了一个正面素材

126
00:04:29,940 --> 00:04:33,748
我这个角色变得更丰满 更正面 更有价值了

127
00:04:33,899 --> 00:04:34,649
换句话说

128
00:04:35,020 --> 00:04:37,178
你做善事的真实动机里

129
00:04:37,180 --> 00:04:38,529
有一个隐秘的成分

130
00:04:38,979 --> 00:04:40,469
不是为了对方好

131
00:04:40,539 --> 00:04:44,617
而是为了巩固我是一个好人这个自我模型

132
00:04:44,847 --> 00:04:48,136
唯识学在一千多年前就看透了这件事

133
00:04:48,247 --> 00:04:49,737
它的描述更精确

134
00:04:50,047 --> 00:04:50,756
唯识学说

135
00:04:51,088 --> 00:04:52,646
你所有的意识活动

136
00:04:52,648 --> 00:04:55,376
不管是思考 判断 还是行善

137
00:04:55,408 --> 00:04:58,136
都要经过第七识末那识的审批

138
00:04:58,367 --> 00:05:00,256
末那识的工作只有一个

139
00:05:00,367 --> 00:05:03,177
给所有信息盖上一个我的标签

140
00:05:03,408 --> 00:05:04,316
你看到一朵花

141
00:05:04,648 --> 00:05:05,737
末那识盖章

142
00:05:05,768 --> 00:05:06,896
我看到的

143
00:05:07,047 --> 00:05:08,196
你产生一个想法

144
00:05:08,408 --> 00:05:09,446
末那识盖章

145
00:05:09,448 --> 00:05:10,496
我的想法

146
00:05:10,607 --> 00:05:11,717
你做了一件善事

147
00:05:11,927 --> 00:05:13,326
末那识立刻盖章

148
00:05:13,328 --> 00:05:14,336
我的功德

149
00:05:14,607 --> 00:05:17,367
这个盖章过程是自动的 无意识的

150
00:05:17,367 --> 00:05:18,297
你拦不住

151
00:05:18,367 --> 00:05:20,686
就像你呼吸不需要思考一样

152
00:05:20,687 --> 00:05:22,929
末那识盖章也不需要你同意

153
00:05:23,319 --> 00:05:25,028
所以梁武帝的问题出在哪里

154
00:05:25,480 --> 00:05:27,609
不是出在他做的善事不够多

155
00:05:27,840 --> 00:05:29,809
也不是出在他求回报

156
00:05:30,239 --> 00:05:33,009
他的问题出在他问出了那个问题本身

157
00:05:33,400 --> 00:05:34,669
朕做了这么多功德

158
00:05:35,080 --> 00:05:36,069
功德有多大

159
00:05:36,720 --> 00:05:37,388
这句话里

160
00:05:37,639 --> 00:05:39,888
有一个实心的朕在施予

161
00:05:40,040 --> 00:05:42,689
有十几万实心的僧人在接受

162
00:05:42,920 --> 00:05:45,328
有无数实心的寺庙被建成

163
00:05:45,720 --> 00:05:46,509
三轮俱全

164
00:05:46,879 --> 00:05:48,009
三轮俱实

165
00:05:48,319 --> 00:05:51,609
末那识在每一座寺庙的地基上都盖了章

166
00:05:51,679 --> 00:05:52,689
上面写着

167
00:05:52,720 --> 00:05:53,729
梁武帝的

168
00:05:54,080 --> 00:05:57,249
达摩看见的不是梁武帝的善行不够多

169
00:05:57,400 --> 00:05:59,208
而是一个结构性问题

170
00:05:59,960 --> 00:06:01,888
只要这个盖章机在运转

171
00:06:01,920 --> 00:06:03,328
你建再多的庙

172
00:06:03,360 --> 00:06:06,500
都只是在给我这个幻觉添砖加瓦

173
00:06:07,012 --> 00:06:09,500
这就是为什么达摩说并无功德

174
00:06:09,531 --> 00:06:11,180
而不是说功德很小

175
00:06:11,452 --> 00:06:13,021
功德不是大小的问题

176
00:06:13,492 --> 00:06:14,721
三轮是实心的

177
00:06:14,932 --> 00:06:16,021
功德为零

178
00:06:16,252 --> 00:06:18,531
不是因为善行本身没有价值

179
00:06:18,531 --> 00:06:19,760
而是因为末那识

180
00:06:20,052 --> 00:06:21,690
把善行的所有能量

181
00:06:21,692 --> 00:06:23,581
都吸收进我的堡垒里了

182
00:06:23,851 --> 00:06:25,221
你以为你在利他

183
00:06:25,332 --> 00:06:28,065
其实你在加固自己的城墙

184
00:06:28,575 --> 00:06:30,525
那三轮体空到底是什么状态

185
00:06:31,056 --> 00:06:34,585
我试着用一个你大概率体验过的瞬间来说明

186
00:06:34,976 --> 00:06:35,765
你走在路上

187
00:06:36,056 --> 00:06:37,705
看到一个老人摔倒了

188
00:06:37,976 --> 00:06:39,664
你冲过去把他扶起来

189
00:06:39,895 --> 00:06:40,244
注意

190
00:06:40,575 --> 00:06:42,424
在你冲过去的那一秒钟

191
00:06:42,536 --> 00:06:46,325
你的大脑里有我要去做一件好事这个念头吗

192
00:06:47,015 --> 00:06:48,104
大概率没有

193
00:06:48,455 --> 00:06:49,484
你只是看见了

194
00:06:49,736 --> 00:06:51,145
然后身体动了

195
00:06:51,536 --> 00:06:52,325
那一秒钟里

196
00:06:52,655 --> 00:06:54,104
没有我在计算

197
00:06:54,215 --> 00:06:55,484
没有对方被评估

198
00:06:55,895 --> 00:06:57,465
没有好事被定义

199
00:06:57,856 --> 00:06:59,625
只有一个事件在发生

200
00:06:59,900 --> 00:07:00,700
扶

201
00:07:01,095 --> 00:07:01,765
那一秒钟

202
00:07:02,135 --> 00:07:03,544
就是三轮体空

203
00:07:03,936 --> 00:07:05,385
不是你修出来的

204
00:07:05,455 --> 00:07:08,932
是你来不及制造三轮的那个空档

205
00:07:09,363 --> 00:07:10,151
但问题是

206
00:07:10,603 --> 00:07:11,731
一秒钟之后

207
00:07:11,803 --> 00:07:13,492
末那识就追上来了

208
00:07:13,882 --> 00:07:15,231
它立刻开始盖章

209
00:07:15,803 --> 00:07:17,171
我扶了一个老人

210
00:07:17,603 --> 00:07:20,572
然后默认模式网络开始编织故事

211
00:07:20,682 --> 00:07:22,211
我是一个善良的人

212
00:07:22,803 --> 00:07:24,481
如果老人说了声谢谢

213
00:07:24,483 --> 00:07:25,932
故事就更完整了

214
00:07:26,163 --> 00:07:28,081
如果老人头也不回走了

215
00:07:28,082 --> 00:07:30,211
你心里可能会有一丝失落

216
00:07:30,562 --> 00:07:32,072
这丝失落从哪来

217
00:07:32,723 --> 00:07:36,231
从那个已经被末那识盖了章的我来的

218
00:07:36,822 --> 00:07:40,870
所以三轮体空不是一个你靠道德修养能达到的境界

219
00:07:41,101 --> 00:07:42,740
我要做到三轮体空

220
00:07:42,741 --> 00:07:45,231
这个念头本身就是三轮俱实

221
00:07:45,462 --> 00:07:46,671
因为有一个我

222
00:07:46,702 --> 00:07:49,231
要去做到一个叫三轮体空的目标

223
00:07:49,622 --> 00:07:51,810
施者 受者 所施之物

224
00:07:52,022 --> 00:07:52,901
一个不少

225
00:07:52,901 --> 00:07:54,190
全是实心的

226
00:07:54,541 --> 00:07:57,070
这就是修行中最精妙的悖论

227
00:07:57,382 --> 00:07:59,221
你不能追求三轮体空

228
00:07:59,221 --> 00:08:01,911
因为追求本身就重建了三轮

229
00:08:02,262 --> 00:08:03,950
你只能在某个瞬间

230
00:08:03,981 --> 00:08:06,971
发现三轮从来就不是实心的

231
00:08:07,202 --> 00:08:11,531
预测编码理论给这个悖论提供了一个特别清晰的解释

232
00:08:11,762 --> 00:08:14,051
你的大脑是一台预测机器

233
00:08:14,163 --> 00:08:16,601
它不是被动接收世界的信息

234
00:08:16,603 --> 00:08:18,851
而是主动向世界发出预测

235
00:08:18,923 --> 00:08:21,651
然后用实际输入来校验

236
00:08:21,882 --> 00:08:23,291
你做善事之前

237
00:08:23,363 --> 00:08:25,731
大脑已经有一个先验信念

238
00:08:25,842 --> 00:08:27,651
我是一个善良的人

239
00:08:27,842 --> 00:08:29,491
做善事这个行为

240
00:08:29,522 --> 00:08:32,361
在很多时候不完全是自发的

241
00:08:32,363 --> 00:08:34,812
而是在验证这个先验信念

242
00:08:35,043 --> 00:08:37,652
当善行的结果与预测吻合

243
00:08:37,722 --> 00:08:39,111
比如对方感谢你了

244
00:08:39,442 --> 00:08:41,131
先验信念被确认

245
00:08:41,242 --> 00:08:44,131
我是善良的这个模型被巩固

246
00:08:44,683 --> 00:08:45,792
当结果不吻合

247
00:08:46,082 --> 00:08:47,481
比如对方没理你

248
00:08:47,482 --> 00:08:48,432
你感到不舒服

249
00:08:48,643 --> 00:08:50,332
因为预测失败了

250
00:08:51,003 --> 00:08:52,202
在这个框架里

251
00:08:52,202 --> 00:08:54,481
很多看起来无私的善行

252
00:08:54,482 --> 00:08:57,052
背后藏着一个隐秘的函数

253
00:08:57,442 --> 00:09:00,611
大脑在做自我模型的维护保养

254
00:09:01,003 --> 00:09:02,532
你不是在帮别人

255
00:09:02,563 --> 00:09:06,123
你是在帮你的大脑确认我是谁

256
00:09:06,553 --> 00:09:08,282
你可以做一个简单的测试

257
00:09:08,673 --> 00:09:11,123
回忆一下你最近做过的一件好事

258
00:09:11,553 --> 00:09:12,522
然后问自己

259
00:09:12,873 --> 00:09:15,883
如果这件好事永远不会有任何人知道

260
00:09:16,033 --> 00:09:18,123
包括你自己事后也会忘记

261
00:09:18,354 --> 00:09:19,143
你还会做吗

262
00:09:20,074 --> 00:09:21,263
你的第一反应大概是

263
00:09:21,673 --> 00:09:22,483
当然会

264
00:09:23,074 --> 00:09:24,723
但你再仔细感受一下

265
00:09:25,074 --> 00:09:27,123
如果连你自己都不会记得

266
00:09:27,234 --> 00:09:30,562
这件事对你的自我叙事完全没有任何贡献

267
00:09:30,793 --> 00:09:33,503
你心里是不是有什么东西微微塌了一下

268
00:09:34,434 --> 00:09:36,162
那个微微塌下去的东西

269
00:09:36,354 --> 00:09:38,123
就是末那识在抗议

270
00:09:38,434 --> 00:09:38,782
它说

271
00:09:39,234 --> 00:09:40,792
如果我连记都记不住

272
00:09:40,793 --> 00:09:42,302
那这件事对我有什么意义

273
00:09:43,317 --> 00:09:44,118
你看

274
00:09:44,153 --> 00:09:47,906
末那识连好事的意义都要经过我的审批

275
00:09:48,578 --> 00:09:51,627
三轮体空要打断的就是这个循环

276
00:09:52,057 --> 00:09:54,587
它不是说你不应该做好事

277
00:09:54,978 --> 00:09:55,446
它是说

278
00:09:55,858 --> 00:09:56,946
有没有可能

279
00:09:57,098 --> 00:09:58,046
做好事的时候

280
00:09:58,458 --> 00:10:00,046
不是为了确认我是谁

281
00:10:00,777 --> 00:10:01,607
有没有可能

282
00:10:01,978 --> 00:10:03,306
帮助发生了

283
00:10:03,417 --> 00:10:05,406
但没有一个在帮助的我

284
00:10:06,377 --> 00:10:09,267
金刚经里有一句话说得极其精准

285
00:10:09,458 --> 00:10:10,416
菩萨于法

286
00:10:10,417 --> 00:10:11,367
应无所住

287
00:10:11,738 --> 00:10:12,786
行于布施

288
00:10:13,218 --> 00:10:13,847
无所住

289
00:10:14,297 --> 00:10:16,227
就是末那识没有盖章

290
00:10:16,657 --> 00:10:17,446
行于布施

291
00:10:17,818 --> 00:10:19,946
就是善行照常发生

292
00:10:20,338 --> 00:10:22,587
善行不是从我出发的

293
00:10:22,777 --> 00:10:25,946
善行是从缘起中自然涌现的

294
00:10:26,098 --> 00:10:27,666
就像水往低处流

295
00:10:27,698 --> 00:10:31,084
不需要一个我在决定往哪流

296
00:10:31,634 --> 00:10:32,474
讲到这里

297
00:10:32,474 --> 00:10:35,594
我想说说三轮体空和我们之前聊过的回向

298
00:10:35,594 --> 00:10:37,603
有一个关键的递进关系

299
00:10:38,035 --> 00:10:39,143
回向讲的是什么

300
00:10:39,675 --> 00:10:40,783
做完善事之后

301
00:10:41,155 --> 00:10:43,084
主动把功德转出去

302
00:10:43,114 --> 00:10:45,883
不让末那识把它收编进我的账户

303
00:10:46,275 --> 00:10:48,003
这是一个事后操作

304
00:10:48,474 --> 00:10:49,304
你发了工资

305
00:10:49,634 --> 00:10:51,204
然后决定捐出去

306
00:10:51,754 --> 00:10:53,263
三轮体空讲的是什么

307
00:10:53,714 --> 00:10:55,844
在善行发生的那个当下

308
00:10:55,915 --> 00:10:58,684
根本就没有一笔工资被发出来

309
00:10:59,035 --> 00:11:00,704
不是你拿到了再放手

310
00:11:01,075 --> 00:11:02,564
而是从头到尾

311
00:11:02,634 --> 00:11:04,363
手就没有握紧过

312
00:11:04,795 --> 00:11:06,164
回向是训练轮

313
00:11:06,315 --> 00:11:08,763
三轮体空是不再需要训练轮

314
00:11:09,474 --> 00:11:12,403
回向是有意识地改写末那识的标签

315
00:11:12,594 --> 00:11:16,522
三轮体空是末那识在那一刻根本没来盖章

316
00:11:16,873 --> 00:11:19,443
这个递进在修行中特别重要

317
00:11:19,753 --> 00:11:22,042
你不可能一上来就三轮体空

318
00:11:22,273 --> 00:11:25,963
就像你不可能不用辅助轮就直接骑自行车

319
00:11:26,314 --> 00:11:28,282
回向就是那个辅助轮

320
00:11:28,594 --> 00:11:31,723
你先练习做完好事之后有意识地放开

321
00:11:31,913 --> 00:11:33,552
练到足够多次之后

322
00:11:33,554 --> 00:11:36,032
你才有可能在某个瞬间体验到

323
00:11:36,033 --> 00:11:39,348
做好事的时候手就没握过

324
00:11:39,739 --> 00:11:43,309
但我要提醒一个很多修行者容易掉进去的坑

325
00:11:43,780 --> 00:11:46,309
有些人听了三轮体空的道理之后

326
00:11:46,459 --> 00:11:49,029
做好事的时候就开始监控自己

327
00:11:49,459 --> 00:11:50,728
我有没有在记账

328
00:11:51,420 --> 00:11:52,848
我有没有三轮体空

329
00:11:53,500 --> 00:11:55,169
我的末那识盖章了没有

330
00:11:55,739 --> 00:11:57,789
这恰恰是最重的三轮

331
00:11:57,979 --> 00:11:59,628
你在施予的同时

332
00:11:59,660 --> 00:12:02,309
你的末那识在监控你的末那识

333
00:12:02,620 --> 00:12:03,929
这不是一层盖章

334
00:12:04,180 --> 00:12:05,669
这是两层盖章

335
00:12:06,140 --> 00:12:08,388
禅宗有一个说法特别到位

336
00:12:08,459 --> 00:12:10,029
叫骑驴找驴

337
00:12:10,339 --> 00:12:11,488
你骑在驴背上

338
00:12:11,780 --> 00:12:12,868
到处问人

339
00:12:12,979 --> 00:12:14,329
请问驴在哪里

340
00:12:15,059 --> 00:12:16,488
末那识就是那头驴

341
00:12:16,939 --> 00:12:18,388
你用它来找它

342
00:12:18,420 --> 00:12:19,572
永远找不到

343
00:12:19,963 --> 00:12:20,712
那到底怎么办

344
00:12:21,203 --> 00:12:23,972
我分享一个对我自己触动很大的理解

345
00:12:24,404 --> 00:12:27,612
三轮体空不是一个你需要做到的状态

346
00:12:27,884 --> 00:12:29,492
它是你本来的状态

347
00:12:29,803 --> 00:12:32,533
在末那识盖章之前的那个瞬间

348
00:12:32,723 --> 00:12:34,533
三轮本来就是空的

349
00:12:34,884 --> 00:12:35,793
帮助发生了

350
00:12:36,004 --> 00:12:37,533
只有帮助在发生

351
00:12:37,884 --> 00:12:38,553
没有施者

352
00:12:38,843 --> 00:12:39,513
没有受者

353
00:12:39,764 --> 00:12:41,053
没有所施之物

354
00:12:41,323 --> 00:12:43,293
就像一滴水落进大海

355
00:12:43,764 --> 00:12:45,992
你说这滴水在施予大海什么呢

356
00:12:46,604 --> 00:12:47,913
大海在接受什么呢

357
00:12:48,524 --> 00:12:50,553
被施予的东西又是什么呢

358
00:12:51,244 --> 00:12:54,173
这三个问题在那一刻根本不成立

359
00:12:54,524 --> 00:12:55,433
水归于水

360
00:12:55,843 --> 00:12:57,623
只是一个事件在发生

361
00:12:58,215 --> 00:12:59,324
只是半秒钟之后

362
00:12:59,695 --> 00:13:01,423
末那识追上来了

363
00:13:01,854 --> 00:13:02,163
它说

364
00:13:02,535 --> 00:13:03,944
那滴水是我

365
00:13:04,254 --> 00:13:05,243
大海是他

366
00:13:05,734 --> 00:13:08,104
落下去这件事是我的善行

367
00:13:08,575 --> 00:13:10,944
三轮就这样被制造出来了

368
00:13:11,455 --> 00:13:14,503
所以修行不是去创造三轮体空

369
00:13:14,935 --> 00:13:18,263
修行是看见三轮是怎么被制造出来的

370
00:13:18,575 --> 00:13:20,003
你看见了制造过程

371
00:13:20,335 --> 00:13:21,984
制造就松动了

372
00:13:22,215 --> 00:13:25,128
看见本身就是解药

373
00:13:25,599 --> 00:13:27,238
这就是为什么禅宗说

374
00:13:27,239 --> 00:13:30,447
真正的修行不是坐在蒲团上用力观照

375
00:13:30,599 --> 00:13:33,605
而是在你忘了自己在修行的那些时刻

376
00:13:33,875 --> 00:13:36,085
炒菜的时候忘了自己在炒菜

377
00:13:36,196 --> 00:13:37,685
只有炒菜在发生

378
00:13:38,076 --> 00:13:40,244
走路的时候忘了自己在走路

379
00:13:40,316 --> 00:13:41,764
只有走路在发生

380
00:13:42,156 --> 00:13:44,365
帮人的时候忘了自己在帮人

381
00:13:44,436 --> 00:13:45,845
只有帮在发生

382
00:13:46,275 --> 00:13:48,685
三轮体空不是一种特殊能力

383
00:13:48,836 --> 00:13:51,355
它是你卸下了一个多余的东西之后

384
00:13:51,355 --> 00:13:53,680
自然露出来的底色

385
00:13:53,951 --> 00:13:54,751
讲到这里

386
00:13:54,751 --> 00:13:57,441
我想回应一下触发这一期的那条留言

387
00:13:57,911 --> 00:14:01,081
有一位观众看完龙树中论那期之后问

388
00:14:01,312 --> 00:14:03,201
能不能讲讲三轮体空

389
00:14:03,432 --> 00:14:05,001
这个问题问得特别好

390
00:14:05,151 --> 00:14:09,280
因为三轮体空和中论的核心逻辑是一脉相承的

391
00:14:09,631 --> 00:14:11,121
龙树的八不中道

392
00:14:11,151 --> 00:14:15,160
不生不灭 不常不断 不一不异 不来不去

393
00:14:15,352 --> 00:14:16,501
本质上在说什么

394
00:14:16,911 --> 00:14:19,760
在说你以为的所有实心的东西

395
00:14:19,911 --> 00:14:21,550
其实都是缘起的

396
00:14:21,552 --> 00:14:23,241
没有独立的自性

397
00:14:23,592 --> 00:14:26,760
三轮体空就是把龙树这个哲学洞见

398
00:14:26,792 --> 00:14:29,481
拉到了你每天都在做的事情上面

399
00:14:30,151 --> 00:14:31,680
你帮别人拿了一杯水

400
00:14:31,712 --> 00:14:33,441
你给陌生人让了一个座位

401
00:14:33,511 --> 00:14:35,520
你对同事说了一句鼓励的话

402
00:14:35,792 --> 00:14:37,800
在这些最日常的场景里

403
00:14:37,832 --> 00:14:41,810
去验证龙树说的那个空到底是什么感觉

404
00:14:42,242 --> 00:14:44,731
达摩当年对梁武帝还说了一句话

405
00:14:44,801 --> 00:14:46,371
叫净智妙圆

406
00:14:46,482 --> 00:14:47,771
体自空寂

407
00:14:48,002 --> 00:14:48,790
如是功德

408
00:14:49,161 --> 00:14:50,371
不以世求

409
00:14:50,681 --> 00:14:51,910
翻译成大白话就是

410
00:14:52,322 --> 00:14:53,440
真正的功德

411
00:14:53,441 --> 00:14:55,570
不是你在世间做了多少事

412
00:14:55,681 --> 00:14:56,851
而是你的心

413
00:14:56,921 --> 00:14:57,871
在做事的时候

414
00:14:58,362 --> 00:14:59,851
是不是空寂的

415
00:15:00,161 --> 00:15:01,590
空寂不是冷漠

416
00:15:01,842 --> 00:15:02,851
不是无感

417
00:15:03,202 --> 00:15:07,160
空寂是末那识没有盖章的那个状态

418
00:15:08,031 --> 00:15:10,488
最后我想留一个没有答案的问题给你

419
00:15:10,716 --> 00:15:12,483
如果三轮体空的那个瞬间

420
00:15:12,771 --> 00:15:13,806
我不在了

421
00:15:13,838 --> 00:15:14,854
对方也不在了

422
00:15:15,259 --> 00:15:17,282
善行本身也不在了

423
00:15:17,353 --> 00:15:19,910
那到底是什么在让帮助发生

424
00:15:20,514 --> 00:15:24,314
那个在末那识盖章之前就已经在运作的东西

425
00:15:24,582 --> 00:15:25,598
它到底是什么

426
00:15:26,083 --> 00:15:28,501
你现在给不了自己答案没关系

427
00:15:28,729 --> 00:15:30,042
但如果你愿意

428
00:15:30,072 --> 00:15:32,294
下次帮别人做一件小事的时候

429
00:15:32,482 --> 00:15:35,058
留意一下那个最初的一秒钟

430
00:15:35,484 --> 00:15:39,521
在我在帮他这个念头出现之前的那一秒钟

431
00:15:39,868 --> 00:15:40,608
那一秒里面

432
00:15:40,896 --> 00:15:41,477
有什么

433
00:15:41,922 --> 00:15:43,215
如果你觉察到了什么

434
00:15:43,503 --> 00:15:44,855
哪怕说不清楚

435
00:15:44,965 --> 00:15:46,830
都可以来评论区聊聊

436
00:15:47,572 --> 00:15:50,820
我特别好奇你们在那一秒钟里看见了什么

437
00:15:50,968 --> 00:15:51,629
我是王利杰

438
00:15:51,916 --> 00:15:53,032
我们下期见