1
00:00:00,264 --> 00:00:01,334
龙树证明了空

2
00:00:01,784 --> 00:00:03,515
差点把佛教证没了

3
00:00:03,744 --> 00:00:04,775
他用了一辈子

4
00:00:05,064 --> 00:00:06,054
证明了一件事

5
00:00:06,583 --> 00:00:08,994
世间万物没有固定的本质

6
00:00:09,064 --> 00:00:10,234
一切都是空

7
00:00:10,663 --> 00:00:12,875
这个发现改变了整个佛教

8
00:00:13,144 --> 00:00:14,455
但龙树没想到的是

9
00:00:14,784 --> 00:00:15,994
他证明完之后

10
00:00:16,103 --> 00:00:17,754
佛教自己出了问题

11
00:00:18,554 --> 00:00:18,906
哈喽

12
00:00:19,235 --> 00:00:19,706
大家好

13
00:00:20,154 --> 00:00:21,286
我是王利杰

14
00:00:21,674 --> 00:00:23,845
上期我们讲了两兄弟的故事

15
00:00:24,075 --> 00:00:26,273
无著在山洞里坐了十二年

16
00:00:26,275 --> 00:00:27,325
等一个答案

17
00:00:27,595 --> 00:00:29,566
世亲号称千部论主

18
00:00:29,714 --> 00:00:32,486
从反对大乘到全力投入唯识

19
00:00:32,874 --> 00:00:34,486
他们的故事很传奇

20
00:00:34,634 --> 00:00:36,685
但我故意留了一个问题没说

21
00:00:37,203 --> 00:00:38,633
他们到底在解决什么问题

22
00:00:39,283 --> 00:00:41,573
为什么佛教在那个历史时刻

23
00:00:41,603 --> 00:00:42,914
非得有唯识学不可

24
00:00:43,603 --> 00:00:44,774
今天这一期

25
00:00:44,802 --> 00:00:48,613
是整个系列到目前为止最关键的一次转折

26
00:00:48,883 --> 00:00:51,642
我们要看的不是某个人的传奇故事

27
00:00:51,643 --> 00:00:53,613
而是一整个思想体系

28
00:00:53,722 --> 00:00:57,454
为什么会在公元四世纪的印度被逼着诞生

29
00:00:57,945 --> 00:00:59,715
故事要从龙树说起

30
00:00:59,904 --> 00:01:01,135
龙树的中观哲学

31
00:01:01,504 --> 00:01:03,355
我们花了两期讲过

32
00:01:03,544 --> 00:01:05,616
他做的事情简单说就是一件

33
00:01:06,105 --> 00:01:06,596
拆

34
00:01:06,985 --> 00:01:09,556
任何你以为有固定本质的东西

35
00:01:09,784 --> 00:01:11,584
他都能用逻辑告诉你

36
00:01:11,584 --> 00:01:12,435
它没有

37
00:01:12,784 --> 00:01:14,135
桌子没有桌子性

38
00:01:14,584 --> 00:01:16,036
人没有人性

39
00:01:16,265 --> 00:01:20,476
甚至佛法本身也没有一个固定不变的法性

40
00:01:20,744 --> 00:01:23,676
一切都是因缘和合的暂时显现

41
00:01:23,905 --> 00:01:24,855
缘聚则生

42
00:01:25,224 --> 00:01:27,118
缘散则灭

43
00:01:27,346 --> 00:01:28,458
这个理论精确吗

44
00:01:29,012 --> 00:01:29,812
精确

45
00:01:30,107 --> 00:01:30,738
深刻吗

46
00:01:31,232 --> 00:01:32,032
深刻

47
00:01:32,306 --> 00:01:34,437
但它留下了一个巨大的空白

48
00:01:34,826 --> 00:01:35,877
我打个比方

49
00:01:36,427 --> 00:01:39,118
龙树就像一个极其优秀的审计师

50
00:01:39,546 --> 00:01:41,437
一家公司经营了几百年

51
00:01:41,466 --> 00:01:42,998
账目越来越复杂

52
00:01:43,227 --> 00:01:44,998
很多人在里面动手脚

53
00:01:45,026 --> 00:01:46,838
搞出了一堆虚假资产

54
00:01:47,227 --> 00:01:48,097
龙树走进来

55
00:01:48,427 --> 00:01:49,797
花了几年时间

56
00:01:49,906 --> 00:01:52,758
把每一笔虚假资产全部审了出来

57
00:01:53,026 --> 00:01:54,037
一笔不剩

58
00:01:54,466 --> 00:01:55,138
审完之后

59
00:01:55,507 --> 00:01:56,797
他拍拍手走了

60
00:01:57,266 --> 00:01:59,558
留下一屋子人面面相觑

61
00:02:00,343 --> 00:02:01,822
虚假资产清掉了

62
00:02:01,822 --> 00:02:03,914
但公司还得继续运转

63
00:02:04,182 --> 00:02:06,034
你总不能审完就关门

64
00:02:06,408 --> 00:02:07,207
接下来

65
00:02:07,222 --> 00:02:10,553
佛教内部渐渐浮出了三个绕不过去的问题

66
00:02:10,910 --> 00:02:11,342
第一个

67
00:02:11,630 --> 00:02:12,361
因果

68
00:02:12,670 --> 00:02:15,241
佛教从第一天起就讲因果

69
00:02:15,630 --> 00:02:16,502
你种善因

70
00:02:16,790 --> 00:02:17,461
得善果

71
00:02:17,910 --> 00:02:18,581
种恶因

72
00:02:18,830 --> 00:02:19,761
得恶果

73
00:02:20,110 --> 00:02:22,602
这是整套修行体系的地基

74
00:02:22,991 --> 00:02:25,241
但龙树说一切皆空

75
00:02:25,271 --> 00:02:27,041
一切没有固定本质

76
00:02:27,271 --> 00:02:28,861
那因果挂在哪里

77
00:02:29,648 --> 00:02:30,160
你想想

78
00:02:30,409 --> 00:02:31,739
你做了一件好事

79
00:02:31,768 --> 00:02:34,299
这个善的力量总得有个地方存着

80
00:02:34,448 --> 00:02:36,487
如果万物都没有固定本质

81
00:02:36,488 --> 00:02:38,080
那这个力量存在什么地方

82
00:02:38,569 --> 00:02:39,839
你说因缘和合

83
00:02:40,168 --> 00:02:40,660
好

84
00:02:40,689 --> 00:02:43,160
那因缘和合的过程靠什么在运转

85
00:02:43,729 --> 00:02:45,648
一个公司的CEO跟员工说

86
00:02:45,648 --> 00:02:48,327
我们公司没有任何固定的制度和架构

87
00:02:48,328 --> 00:02:50,059
一切都是缘起性空

88
00:02:50,167 --> 00:02:50,928
员工问

89
00:02:50,928 --> 00:02:52,920
那我上个月的工资打到哪个账户

90
00:02:53,328 --> 00:02:53,880
CEO说

91
00:02:54,168 --> 00:02:55,459
账户也是空的

92
00:02:55,569 --> 00:02:57,160
你觉得这个公司能撑几天

93
00:02:58,415 --> 00:02:58,886
第二个

94
00:02:59,214 --> 00:02:59,905
积累

95
00:03:00,214 --> 00:03:02,185
修行不是一蹴而就的

96
00:03:02,415 --> 00:03:03,245
你打一次坐

97
00:03:03,614 --> 00:03:04,826
观一次呼吸

98
00:03:04,894 --> 00:03:06,106
种一次善因

99
00:03:06,214 --> 00:03:09,085
这些微小的努力到底存放在什么地方

100
00:03:09,894 --> 00:03:11,785
我自己也有过这种感受

101
00:03:12,135 --> 00:03:15,266
有一段时间我读中观的东西读得很投入

102
00:03:15,415 --> 00:03:17,946
觉得空性这个概念精彩绝伦

103
00:03:18,415 --> 00:03:19,585
但读着读着

104
00:03:19,614 --> 00:03:21,285
有一天突然冒出一个念头

105
00:03:21,695 --> 00:03:23,745
我每天花一个小时打坐

106
00:03:23,894 --> 00:03:25,046
按照龙树的说法

107
00:03:25,334 --> 00:03:26,745
连我都是空的

108
00:03:26,815 --> 00:03:29,366
那这一个小时的努力算是谁在努力

109
00:03:29,855 --> 00:03:32,046
努力的结果又存放在什么地方

110
00:03:32,575 --> 00:03:34,694
如果连一个存放的地方都没有

111
00:03:34,695 --> 00:03:37,486
那修行不就是往一个没有底的桶里倒水

112
00:03:38,774 --> 00:03:40,946
这个问题在当时非常现实

113
00:03:41,054 --> 00:03:44,666
很多修行者坐在蒲团上认认真真修了几十年

114
00:03:44,734 --> 00:03:46,733
中观的学者跑来告诉他

115
00:03:46,734 --> 00:03:50,386
你修的那些东西没有任何一个固定的地方在存放

116
00:03:50,734 --> 00:03:52,726
你说这个修行者心里什么感受

117
00:03:53,329 --> 00:03:54,800
第三个问题最根本

118
00:03:55,088 --> 00:03:55,819
轮回

119
00:03:56,288 --> 00:03:58,300
佛教从一开始就讲轮回

120
00:03:58,729 --> 00:04:01,020
你这辈子的行为影响下辈子

121
00:04:01,528 --> 00:04:04,060
但佛陀在第一堂课就讲了无我

122
00:04:04,489 --> 00:04:06,539
没有一个恒常不变的灵魂

123
00:04:06,929 --> 00:04:08,060
那问题来了

124
00:04:08,408 --> 00:04:09,659
如果没有灵魂

125
00:04:09,769 --> 00:04:12,360
到底是谁从这辈子跳到下辈子

126
00:04:12,881 --> 00:04:14,812
你不能说有一个灵魂在跑

127
00:04:14,881 --> 00:04:17,532
因为那就变成了婆罗门教的梵我论

128
00:04:17,681 --> 00:04:20,371
佛陀费了半辈子反对的就是这个

129
00:04:20,520 --> 00:04:22,332
你也不能说什么都没有在跑

130
00:04:22,361 --> 00:04:24,280
因为那等于说轮回是假的

131
00:04:24,280 --> 00:04:25,571
因果也是假的

132
00:04:25,640 --> 00:04:28,051
整个佛教修行体系就塌了

133
00:04:28,361 --> 00:04:31,251
我知道评论区有朋友早就在问这个问题了

134
00:04:31,481 --> 00:04:32,751
佛教一边说无我

135
00:04:32,960 --> 00:04:34,212
一边说轮回

136
00:04:34,241 --> 00:04:35,472
这不是自相矛盾吗

137
00:04:36,241 --> 00:04:38,452
一千五百年前的佛教修行者

138
00:04:38,520 --> 00:04:40,532
其实也被这个问题折磨着

139
00:04:40,720 --> 00:04:42,719
这三个问题像三颗钉子

140
00:04:42,720 --> 00:04:44,732
扎在中观学派的地板上

141
00:04:45,041 --> 00:04:46,551
谁都知道空是对的

142
00:04:46,760 --> 00:04:47,852
但光说空

143
00:04:47,905 --> 00:04:48,714
不够用

144
00:04:48,969 --> 00:04:50,421
其实在无著之前

145
00:04:50,529 --> 00:04:53,020
已经有人试着回答过这些问题了

146
00:04:53,250 --> 00:04:54,541
说一切有部

147
00:04:54,769 --> 00:04:58,341
就是我们之前讲过的佛教里最像物理学家的那个学派

148
00:04:58,529 --> 00:04:59,680
他们的回答很直接

149
00:05:00,130 --> 00:05:01,341
法体恒有

150
00:05:01,649 --> 00:05:03,781
他们说万物的基本元素

151
00:05:03,810 --> 00:05:06,301
那些叫做法的基本存在单元

152
00:05:06,329 --> 00:05:07,781
是恒常存在的

153
00:05:07,930 --> 00:05:10,620
过去的法 现在的法 未来的法

154
00:05:10,690 --> 00:05:12,101
法体本身不变

155
00:05:12,169 --> 00:05:13,868
只是它的作用在变

156
00:05:14,298 --> 00:05:15,409
因果挂在哪里

157
00:05:15,858 --> 00:05:17,949
挂在这些恒有的法体上

158
00:05:18,298 --> 00:05:19,569
修行积累在哪里

159
00:05:20,017 --> 00:05:21,788
在法体的持续中

160
00:05:22,337 --> 00:05:23,129
谁在轮回

161
00:05:23,697 --> 00:05:26,149
法体的不断组合在轮回

162
00:05:27,439 --> 00:05:29,249
这个回答听起来挺利索

163
00:05:29,278 --> 00:05:30,689
但有一个致命的问题

164
00:05:31,198 --> 00:05:32,877
如果法体是恒有的

165
00:05:32,879 --> 00:05:34,970
那它就有固定不变的本质

166
00:05:35,198 --> 00:05:36,929
而龙树已经证明了

167
00:05:37,078 --> 00:05:40,730
任何有固定本质的东西都经不起逻辑检验

168
00:05:41,038 --> 00:05:43,078
所以说一切有部的答案

169
00:05:43,078 --> 00:05:45,410
等于是退回到了龙树之前

170
00:05:45,919 --> 00:05:48,037
龙树好不容易做完的手术

171
00:05:48,038 --> 00:05:50,078
他们又把肿瘤装回去了

172
00:05:50,078 --> 00:05:51,929
佛教需要一个新的答案

173
00:05:52,239 --> 00:05:54,170
这个答案既不能否认空

174
00:05:54,239 --> 00:05:56,809
也不能因为空就放弃因果

175
00:05:57,119 --> 00:05:59,489
它必须站在空和有的中间

176
00:05:59,598 --> 00:06:00,889
两边都不倒

177
00:06:01,981 --> 00:06:04,032
这不是一个纯粹的哲学争论

178
00:06:04,381 --> 00:06:07,712
当时印度的修行者群体里已经出现了迷茫

179
00:06:08,181 --> 00:06:10,991
有人听完中观之后直接放弃了修行

180
00:06:11,181 --> 00:06:12,912
说既然一切都是空的

181
00:06:12,981 --> 00:06:13,491
修什么

182
00:06:14,181 --> 00:06:16,592
也有人退回去抱紧说一切有部

183
00:06:16,741 --> 00:06:17,832
说空是空

184
00:06:17,981 --> 00:06:20,951
但我们修行的那套东西必须是实有的

185
00:06:21,381 --> 00:06:23,472
佛教正在从内部裂开

186
00:06:24,529 --> 00:06:27,380
这就是无著登场的真正背景

187
00:06:27,688 --> 00:06:31,539
他不是坐在书房里想出了一套漂亮的哲学

188
00:06:31,929 --> 00:06:33,419
他是被逼的

189
00:06:33,929 --> 00:06:37,380
整个佛教思想史走到了一个十字路口

190
00:06:37,649 --> 00:06:39,380
不解决这三个问题

191
00:06:39,688 --> 00:06:43,219
佛教哲学就会在逻辑上自相矛盾

192
00:06:43,481 --> 00:06:45,151
无著给出的答案是一个字

193
00:06:45,721 --> 00:06:46,211
识

194
00:06:46,560 --> 00:06:47,851
万法唯识

195
00:06:48,161 --> 00:06:49,572
你经验到的一切

196
00:06:49,601 --> 00:06:52,531
不是外面有一个独立的世界在等着你去看

197
00:06:52,721 --> 00:06:56,611
而是你的意识在每一个瞬间把体验刷新出来

198
00:06:57,000 --> 00:06:58,731
这不是说世界不存在

199
00:06:58,921 --> 00:07:00,291
而是说你的体验

200
00:07:00,360 --> 00:07:02,761
全是意识活动的产物

201
00:07:02,790 --> 00:07:04,870
为了让这个答案真正落地

202
00:07:04,870 --> 00:07:07,201
无著搭建了一套意识架构

203
00:07:07,591 --> 00:07:09,721
最底层叫阿赖耶识

204
00:07:09,990 --> 00:07:10,841
藏识

205
00:07:11,350 --> 00:07:12,521
就是一个仓库

206
00:07:12,711 --> 00:07:15,802
你做过的每一件事 起过的每一个念头

207
00:07:15,910 --> 00:07:18,562
都在这个仓库里留下一颗种子

208
00:07:18,951 --> 00:07:20,062
种子不是一个东西

209
00:07:20,670 --> 00:07:21,949
它是一种潜能

210
00:07:21,951 --> 00:07:23,201
一种可能性

211
00:07:23,511 --> 00:07:24,302
条件到了

212
00:07:24,591 --> 00:07:25,922
种子就会发芽

213
00:07:25,990 --> 00:07:27,641
变成你当下的体验

214
00:07:27,990 --> 00:07:32,322
你当下的体验又会回头在仓库里种下新的种子

215
00:07:32,670 --> 00:07:33,461
一进一出

216
00:07:33,831 --> 00:07:34,961
永远在转

217
00:07:35,151 --> 00:07:36,081
像一条河

218
00:07:37,067 --> 00:07:38,225
你有没有感觉到

219
00:07:38,227 --> 00:07:39,857
这个画面其实你见过

220
00:07:40,506 --> 00:07:43,677
你的电脑每一秒钟刷新几十次屏幕

221
00:07:43,826 --> 00:07:44,658
每一次刷新

222
00:07:44,987 --> 00:07:46,425
上一帧消失了

223
00:07:46,427 --> 00:07:48,038
新的一帧出现了

224
00:07:48,227 --> 00:07:50,398
没有任何一帧是固定的

225
00:07:50,506 --> 00:07:52,518
但你看到了一个连续的画面

226
00:07:52,867 --> 00:07:55,317
阿赖耶识干的就是这件事

227
00:07:55,667 --> 00:07:58,398
它不是一个固定的灵魂在那里站着

228
00:07:58,547 --> 00:08:00,833
它是一个不停转的过程

229
00:08:01,061 --> 00:08:02,672
龙树留下的三个问题

230
00:08:02,862 --> 00:08:05,552
在这套框架里一次性全解决了

231
00:08:06,181 --> 00:08:07,292
因果挂在哪里

232
00:08:07,741 --> 00:08:08,873
挂在种子上

233
00:08:09,302 --> 00:08:11,513
善因就是一颗善的种子

234
00:08:11,662 --> 00:08:14,472
它不需要挂在一个固定不变的实体上

235
00:08:14,621 --> 00:08:18,792
它只需要以潜能的方式存在于阿赖耶识的种子流中

236
00:08:19,542 --> 00:08:20,852
修行积累在哪里

237
00:08:21,302 --> 00:08:22,552
在种子库里

238
00:08:22,741 --> 00:08:24,540
你每一次正念观照

239
00:08:24,542 --> 00:08:27,393
都在往种子库里种一颗新种子

240
00:08:27,662 --> 00:08:29,753
这颗种子将来会发芽

241
00:08:30,342 --> 00:08:31,333
轮回的是谁

242
00:08:31,941 --> 00:08:33,592
不是一个固定的灵魂

243
00:08:33,662 --> 00:08:37,193
而是阿赖耶识里那条永不停歇的种子瀑流

244
00:08:37,581 --> 00:08:38,532
水一直在换

245
00:08:38,902 --> 00:08:41,032
但河的模式在延续

246
00:08:41,504 --> 00:08:43,034
然后是三自性

247
00:08:43,423 --> 00:08:44,743
这个概念的细节

248
00:08:44,744 --> 00:08:48,394
我们频道在经典解读系列已经花了好几期来拆

249
00:08:48,783 --> 00:08:51,695
今天在历史脉络这条线上我只说一件事

250
00:08:51,943 --> 00:08:53,274
它解决了什么问题

251
00:08:53,704 --> 00:08:57,955
三自性解释的是你看到的世界怎么被组装出来的

252
00:08:58,183 --> 00:09:00,154
实际的因缘运作是一层

253
00:09:00,344 --> 00:09:03,355
你叠加上去的成见和判断是一层

254
00:09:03,584 --> 00:09:06,874
把成见剥掉后看到的本来面目是一层

255
00:09:07,303 --> 00:09:09,274
空和有不再矛盾了

256
00:09:09,504 --> 00:09:13,435
空说的是你叠加的那些成见没有固定本质

257
00:09:13,823 --> 00:09:17,075
有说的是因缘运作真实发生着

258
00:09:17,384 --> 00:09:20,274
两者指向同一个现实的不同侧面

259
00:09:21,353 --> 00:09:24,364
这是思想史上最精妙的一次救场

260
00:09:24,633 --> 00:09:26,643
无著不是推翻了龙树

261
00:09:26,792 --> 00:09:28,803
他是在龙树拆完之后

262
00:09:28,873 --> 00:09:31,604
在那片废墟上重新建了一栋楼

263
00:09:31,832 --> 00:09:33,683
而且这栋楼的地基

264
00:09:33,712 --> 00:09:36,004
恰恰就是龙树留下的空

265
00:09:37,247 --> 00:09:41,618
世亲在他哥哥搭好的框架上做了一件更极端的事

266
00:09:41,968 --> 00:09:45,819
他把整套唯识学浓缩成了三十首偈颂

267
00:09:46,328 --> 00:09:47,338
六百个字

268
00:09:47,808 --> 00:09:48,899
六百个字

269
00:09:48,928 --> 00:09:53,539
描述了意识从底层到表层的全部运作机制

270
00:09:53,968 --> 00:09:58,138
后来的十大论师花了几百年去注解这六百个字

271
00:09:58,527 --> 00:10:02,138
一千多年后玄奘穿过沙漠走到印度

272
00:10:02,208 --> 00:10:03,579
学了整整五年

273
00:10:03,728 --> 00:10:06,338
然后把它们背回来翻译成中文

274
00:10:06,647 --> 00:10:08,039
这不是简单的缩写

275
00:10:08,527 --> 00:10:09,338
这是蒸馏

276
00:10:10,065 --> 00:10:12,276
世亲年轻时写过七十五法

277
00:10:12,384 --> 00:10:14,036
是说一切有部的人

278
00:10:14,384 --> 00:10:16,955
他后来被哥哥说服转向唯识

279
00:10:17,224 --> 00:10:19,663
一个人从旧阵营跳到新阵营

280
00:10:19,665 --> 00:10:22,636
然后替新阵营写出了最精炼的总纲

281
00:10:23,104 --> 00:10:26,235
这种事在整个思想史上都极其罕见

282
00:10:26,785 --> 00:10:30,796
我第一次读唯识三十颂的时候有一种很奇特的感受

283
00:10:31,185 --> 00:10:34,595
你能感觉到每一个字都是被挤压出来的

284
00:10:34,785 --> 00:10:36,304
没有一个多余的字

285
00:10:36,305 --> 00:10:37,996
也没有一个偷懒的字

286
00:10:38,425 --> 00:10:42,595
就像有人把一整座图书馆的信息压缩成了一张名片

287
00:10:43,641 --> 00:10:44,472
你有没有注意到

288
00:10:44,881 --> 00:10:47,011
从龙树到无著世亲

289
00:10:47,200 --> 00:10:51,311
佛教哲学走了一条跟现代科学几乎一模一样的路

290
00:10:52,080 --> 00:10:52,972
先是破

291
00:10:53,481 --> 00:10:55,011
推翻旧的框架

292
00:10:55,160 --> 00:10:58,372
证明你以为是真的东西其实不是

293
00:10:58,721 --> 00:11:00,252
这是龙树干的事

294
00:11:00,680 --> 00:11:02,852
爱因斯坦干的也是这个事

295
00:11:03,361 --> 00:11:05,771
量子力学干的也是这个事

296
00:11:06,401 --> 00:11:07,452
然后是立

297
00:11:07,881 --> 00:11:11,092
在废墟上重新建一套能用的理论

298
00:11:11,481 --> 00:11:12,551
能解释现象

299
00:11:12,920 --> 00:11:14,171
能做出预测

300
00:11:14,200 --> 00:11:15,572
能指导实践

301
00:11:15,960 --> 00:11:17,492
这是无著干的事

302
00:11:17,920 --> 00:11:21,291
后牛顿时代的物理学家们干的也是这个事

303
00:11:21,598 --> 00:11:22,228
破容易

304
00:11:22,558 --> 00:11:23,248
立难

305
00:11:23,517 --> 00:11:25,929
说一切都不是你以为的那样

306
00:11:25,958 --> 00:11:26,929
是第一步

307
00:11:27,198 --> 00:11:29,348
说那它到底是怎样的

308
00:11:29,598 --> 00:11:30,569
是第二步

309
00:11:30,877 --> 00:11:33,049
第二步永远比第一步难

310
00:11:33,397 --> 00:11:35,169
龙树用了一辈子破

311
00:11:35,358 --> 00:11:37,089
无著用了一辈子立

312
00:11:37,277 --> 00:11:39,929
佛教哲学需要这两步都走完

313
00:11:39,958 --> 00:11:43,163
才算给了修行者一份完整的地图

314
00:11:43,432 --> 00:11:45,102
但这份地图完美吗

315
00:11:45,631 --> 00:11:47,670
我们这个系列一直在做一件事

316
00:11:47,672 --> 00:11:50,351
就是回头看看佛陀最初的教导

317
00:11:50,351 --> 00:11:51,183
然后问一个问题

318
00:11:51,792 --> 00:11:53,030
这个后来的发展

319
00:11:53,032 --> 00:11:55,763
距离佛陀在菩提树下看到的那个东西

320
00:11:55,832 --> 00:11:57,342
是近了还是远了

321
00:11:57,991 --> 00:12:00,082
唯识学的回答其实很微妙

322
00:12:00,256 --> 00:12:01,057
一方面

323
00:12:01,072 --> 00:12:05,082
阿赖耶识和种子理论确实解决了因果和轮回的问题

324
00:12:05,271 --> 00:12:08,763
让佛教的修行体系在逻辑上重新自洽了

325
00:12:08,991 --> 00:12:11,082
这是在深化佛陀的洞见

326
00:12:11,271 --> 00:12:12,023
但另一方面

327
00:12:12,231 --> 00:12:13,311
你有没有觉得

328
00:12:13,312 --> 00:12:15,943
唯识学的体系已经变得非常复杂了

329
00:12:16,351 --> 00:12:21,122
八识 三能变 三自性 种子六义 四分说

330
00:12:21,912 --> 00:12:25,763
佛陀当年在菩提树下看到的是缘起和无我

331
00:12:26,111 --> 00:12:26,962
两个词

332
00:12:27,511 --> 00:12:29,883
现在变成了一整座理论大厦

333
00:12:30,271 --> 00:12:31,822
这座大厦是精密的

334
00:12:32,072 --> 00:12:33,202
是自洽的

335
00:12:33,951 --> 00:12:35,542
但佛陀当年说过一句话

336
00:12:36,032 --> 00:12:37,190
法尚应舍

337
00:12:37,191 --> 00:12:38,282
何况非法

338
00:12:38,591 --> 00:12:40,343
连佛法本身都是筏

339
00:12:40,791 --> 00:12:42,042
用来过河的

340
00:12:42,232 --> 00:12:43,963
过了河就该放下

341
00:12:44,392 --> 00:12:47,083
唯识学这条筏造得太精美了

342
00:12:47,272 --> 00:12:48,223
你舍不舍得放

343
00:12:48,911 --> 00:12:49,751
这个张力

344
00:12:49,752 --> 00:12:52,642
从唯识学诞生那天起就一直存在

345
00:12:52,951 --> 00:12:54,323
后来的很多争论

346
00:12:54,352 --> 00:12:56,843
本质上都在围绕这个问题打转

347
00:12:57,386 --> 00:12:59,996
无著和世亲解决了中观的问题

348
00:13:00,586 --> 00:13:02,876
但他们自己也留下了新的问题

349
00:13:03,266 --> 00:13:05,416
最初那一念无明从哪来的

350
00:13:05,866 --> 00:13:08,156
阿赖耶识不是永恒实体

351
00:13:08,185 --> 00:13:10,656
那它凭什么能一世一世延续

352
00:13:11,145 --> 00:13:11,896
更重要的是

353
00:13:12,226 --> 00:13:14,036
就在他们活着的年代

354
00:13:14,106 --> 00:13:17,276
另一部经典已经在印度流传了几百年

355
00:13:17,506 --> 00:13:19,676
这部经不属于般若系统

356
00:13:19,706 --> 00:13:21,477
也不属于唯识系统

357
00:13:21,586 --> 00:13:23,717
它提出了一个更大胆的主张

358
00:13:23,986 --> 00:13:24,376
它说

359
00:13:24,665 --> 00:13:26,876
你们在争的那些路线之分

360
00:13:26,986 --> 00:13:29,105
阿罗汉的路和菩萨的路

361
00:13:29,106 --> 00:13:31,025
小乘的路和大乘的路

362
00:13:31,025 --> 00:13:33,156
其实根本就是同一条路

363
00:13:33,346 --> 00:13:35,197
这部经叫法华经

364
00:13:35,586 --> 00:13:38,357
它会彻底改变大乘佛教的格局

365
00:13:38,784 --> 00:13:41,834
你觉得唯识学解决了中观的问题之后

366
00:13:41,903 --> 00:13:44,214
它自己又留下了什么新的困惑

367
00:13:44,704 --> 00:13:47,074
欢迎在评论区留下你的思考

368
00:13:47,304 --> 00:13:47,974
我是王利杰

369
00:13:48,344 --> 00:13:49,099
我们下期见