1
00:00:00,299 --> 00:00:03,120
楞严经 问了七次心在哪里

2
00:00:03,178 --> 00:00:04,639
至今没人答对

3
00:00:04,859 --> 00:00:05,860
不妨也问问自己

4
00:00:06,498 --> 00:00:07,360
你的心

5
00:00:07,378 --> 00:00:08,259
究竟在哪儿

6
00:00:08,778 --> 00:00:11,759
不是指胸腔里那颗跳动的血肉器官

7
00:00:11,939 --> 00:00:14,060
而是此刻正在听这段话

8
00:00:14,378 --> 00:00:17,120
正在领会其中意趣的那个觉知

9
00:00:17,259 --> 00:00:18,339
它安住于何处

10
00:00:19,099 --> 00:00:21,519
你或许会下意识指向脑袋

11
00:00:21,618 --> 00:00:23,000
或是摸摸心口

12
00:00:23,765 --> 00:00:24,766
两千五百年前

13
00:00:25,085 --> 00:00:26,587
阿难也被这样问过

14
00:00:26,725 --> 00:00:28,006
他并非寻常弟子

15
00:00:28,366 --> 00:00:30,146
随侍佛陀二十余载

16
00:00:30,366 --> 00:00:31,605
亲闻教法最多

17
00:00:31,605 --> 00:00:32,367
记忆超群

18
00:00:32,646 --> 00:00:34,307
被誉为多闻第一

19
00:00:34,485 --> 00:00:36,947
可佛陀没考他背过多少经文

20
00:00:37,006 --> 00:00:37,807
只问了一句

21
00:00:38,366 --> 00:00:40,564
当初你见我相好庄严

22
00:00:40,566 --> 00:00:42,826
心生欢喜才发心出家

23
00:00:43,045 --> 00:00:44,447
那个生起欢喜的心

24
00:00:44,725 --> 00:00:45,646
到底在哪儿

25
00:00:46,680 --> 00:00:48,221
阿难本以为不难答

26
00:00:48,400 --> 00:00:49,401
他说了一个处所

27
00:00:49,720 --> 00:00:50,480
佛陀摇头

28
00:00:50,959 --> 00:00:51,480
换一个

29
00:00:51,760 --> 00:00:52,758
又被否定

30
00:00:52,760 --> 00:00:55,638
第三个 第四个 直到第七个

31
00:00:55,639 --> 00:00:56,638
七次回答

32
00:00:56,639 --> 00:00:57,821
七次被推翻

33
00:00:57,999 --> 00:01:00,200
这便是 楞严经 最著名的开篇

34
00:01:00,599 --> 00:01:01,861
七处征心

35
00:01:02,633 --> 00:01:02,954
哈喽

36
00:01:03,073 --> 00:01:03,514
大家好

37
00:01:03,633 --> 00:01:04,575
我是王利杰

38
00:01:04,794 --> 00:01:06,032
今天我们要读的

39
00:01:06,033 --> 00:01:09,134
是一部在汉传佛教中分量极重的经典

40
00:01:09,313 --> 00:01:11,115
古人说开悟的楞严

41
00:01:11,434 --> 00:01:12,654
成佛的法华

42
00:01:12,794 --> 00:01:13,833
顺带说一句

43
00:01:13,833 --> 00:01:15,835
这部经的来历本身就有争议

44
00:01:16,113 --> 00:01:17,913
有人认为它是印度原典

45
00:01:17,913 --> 00:01:20,072
也有人认为是中土撰述

46
00:01:20,074 --> 00:01:21,934
争到今天也没有定论

47
00:01:22,033 --> 00:01:23,792
我这期不打算给你答案

48
00:01:23,794 --> 00:01:25,335
只讲它说了什么

49
00:01:25,623 --> 00:01:27,004
在所有佛经里

50
00:01:27,062 --> 00:01:29,644
楞严经 或许最像一部推理小说

51
00:01:29,862 --> 00:01:31,403
它不急着给答案

52
00:01:31,463 --> 00:01:33,742
而是把你自以为正确的见解

53
00:01:33,743 --> 00:01:35,004
一层层剥落

54
00:01:35,222 --> 00:01:38,004
上一期讲 大乘起信论 的一心二门

55
00:01:38,103 --> 00:01:39,183
这一期的 楞严经

56
00:01:39,463 --> 00:01:41,564
便是那把手术刀的升级版

57
00:01:41,864 --> 00:01:43,965
先看阿难的七次试探

58
00:01:44,383 --> 00:01:44,825
第一次

59
00:01:45,183 --> 00:01:46,764
他说心在身内

60
00:01:47,023 --> 00:01:49,284
这是凡夫最直觉的反应

61
00:01:49,623 --> 00:01:50,344
佛陀反问

62
00:01:50,864 --> 00:01:52,022
若心在内

63
00:01:52,023 --> 00:01:53,784
理应先见五脏六腑

64
00:01:54,103 --> 00:01:55,204
再见外物

65
00:01:55,424 --> 00:01:57,545
你能看见自己的心肝脾肺吗

66
00:01:58,183 --> 00:01:59,525
阿难说不能

67
00:01:59,903 --> 00:02:00,825
既不能见内

68
00:02:01,064 --> 00:02:02,245
便不在内

69
00:02:02,866 --> 00:02:03,428
第二次

70
00:02:03,666 --> 00:02:06,127
阿难改口说心在身外

71
00:02:06,386 --> 00:02:06,907
佛陀道

72
00:02:07,306 --> 00:02:08,148
若心在外

73
00:02:08,467 --> 00:02:10,168
身心便互不相干

74
00:02:10,346 --> 00:02:11,548
可针扎手时

75
00:02:11,866 --> 00:02:13,368
心立刻知痛

76
00:02:13,626 --> 00:02:14,467
心既在外

77
00:02:14,746 --> 00:02:16,548
凭什么感知身体的触受

78
00:02:16,987 --> 00:02:18,007
此说不通

79
00:02:18,357 --> 00:02:18,958
第三次

80
00:02:19,317 --> 00:02:20,698
阿难思量后说

81
00:02:20,838 --> 00:02:23,219
心潜藏在感官根门里

82
00:02:23,278 --> 00:02:25,738
就像人躲在琉璃碗后看世界

83
00:02:25,757 --> 00:02:26,559
能见外物

84
00:02:26,798 --> 00:02:28,298
自身却藏在里面

85
00:02:28,477 --> 00:02:28,999
佛陀问

86
00:02:29,357 --> 00:02:31,418
若心躲在眼后向外看

87
00:02:31,437 --> 00:02:33,556
理应同时看见自己的眼睛

88
00:02:33,558 --> 00:02:34,358
你看得见吗

89
00:02:35,374 --> 00:02:35,935
第四次

90
00:02:36,175 --> 00:02:37,215
阿难换了思路

91
00:02:37,494 --> 00:02:38,375
闭眼见暗

92
00:02:38,575 --> 00:02:39,856
是心在看体内

93
00:02:40,374 --> 00:02:41,176
开眼见明

94
00:02:41,334 --> 00:02:42,796
是心在看体外

95
00:02:43,094 --> 00:02:43,896
佛陀破斥

96
00:02:44,295 --> 00:02:45,733
闭眼所见的黑暗

97
00:02:45,735 --> 00:02:47,415
是呈现在面前的境象

98
00:02:47,695 --> 00:02:48,796
属于所见

99
00:02:49,094 --> 00:02:51,396
能见与所见并非一体

100
00:02:51,534 --> 00:02:51,975
况且

101
00:02:52,254 --> 00:02:53,854
若黑暗即是体内

102
00:02:53,855 --> 00:02:55,733
为何睁眼见光明时

103
00:02:55,735 --> 00:02:57,535
没顺便看见自己的脏腑

104
00:02:58,382 --> 00:02:58,983
第五次

105
00:02:59,141 --> 00:03:01,022
阿难说心无定所

106
00:03:01,342 --> 00:03:02,483
随缘而生

107
00:03:02,621 --> 00:03:03,943
哪里有因缘聚合

108
00:03:04,222 --> 00:03:05,363
哪里就有心

109
00:03:05,621 --> 00:03:06,342
佛陀追问

110
00:03:06,861 --> 00:03:08,263
若心随缘而生

111
00:03:08,502 --> 00:03:09,643
便无自体

112
00:03:09,741 --> 00:03:11,022
一个没有本体的东西

113
00:03:11,421 --> 00:03:12,302
凭什么叫心

114
00:03:12,822 --> 00:03:14,983
你说它在因缘汇聚处

115
00:03:15,382 --> 00:03:16,682
缘散即灭

116
00:03:16,741 --> 00:03:18,263
那你熟睡无心时

117
00:03:18,542 --> 00:03:19,582
它又去了哪里

118
00:03:19,999 --> 00:03:20,600
第六次

119
00:03:20,800 --> 00:03:22,399
阿难说心在中间

120
00:03:22,400 --> 00:03:24,341
在感官与外境之间

121
00:03:24,560 --> 00:03:25,080
佛陀问

122
00:03:25,360 --> 00:03:26,200
中间何在

123
00:03:26,639 --> 00:03:28,199
若指得出具体方位

124
00:03:28,199 --> 00:03:29,681
便落回了前文的窠臼

125
00:03:29,999 --> 00:03:30,760
若指不出

126
00:03:30,999 --> 00:03:32,718
中间便只是个虚名

127
00:03:32,719 --> 00:03:34,300
并无实存之处

128
00:03:34,711 --> 00:03:35,353
第七次

129
00:03:35,671 --> 00:03:37,113
阿难已被逼至绝境

130
00:03:37,431 --> 00:03:38,032
索性说

131
00:03:38,431 --> 00:03:39,772
我无所执着

132
00:03:39,792 --> 00:03:40,913
不在内外中间

133
00:03:41,271 --> 00:03:42,932
无所住便是心

134
00:03:43,072 --> 00:03:43,793
佛陀再破

135
00:03:44,032 --> 00:03:44,950
这无所住

136
00:03:44,951 --> 00:03:46,393
究竟是有还是无

137
00:03:46,792 --> 00:03:47,193
若有

138
00:03:47,472 --> 00:03:48,552
便有存在之相

139
00:03:48,912 --> 00:03:49,673
相在何处

140
00:03:50,032 --> 00:03:50,472
若无

141
00:03:50,752 --> 00:03:52,752
岂不与龟毛兔角一样虚幻

142
00:03:53,232 --> 00:03:53,992
七轮交锋

143
00:03:54,312 --> 00:03:55,893
阿难哑口无言

144
00:03:56,431 --> 00:03:57,452
初读此处

145
00:03:57,550 --> 00:03:59,472
许多人会觉得佛陀是在抬杠

146
00:03:59,911 --> 00:04:01,789
每个答案都能挑出毛病

147
00:04:01,790 --> 00:04:02,952
那到底什么才对

148
00:04:03,510 --> 00:04:05,651
我记得自己第一次读这段的时候

149
00:04:05,830 --> 00:04:07,972
坐在书房里发了很久的呆

150
00:04:08,270 --> 00:04:09,852
后来我把书合上

151
00:04:09,871 --> 00:04:11,532
试着自己回答这个问题

152
00:04:12,676 --> 00:04:14,696
我发现不管我怎么想

153
00:04:14,755 --> 00:04:16,737
总是跳不出阿难的那个圈

154
00:04:17,236 --> 00:04:17,997
说在哪里

155
00:04:18,236 --> 00:04:19,256
都有破绽

156
00:04:19,675 --> 00:04:20,557
说不在哪里

157
00:04:20,876 --> 00:04:21,937
也有破绽

158
00:04:22,275 --> 00:04:24,074
最后我忽然意识到

159
00:04:24,076 --> 00:04:25,696
可能不是答案的问题

160
00:04:25,876 --> 00:04:27,177
是问法的问题

161
00:04:27,565 --> 00:04:29,426
佛陀并非刻意刁难

162
00:04:29,445 --> 00:04:33,106
而是要逼阿难看透所有答案背后共通的谬误

163
00:04:33,366 --> 00:04:34,007
什么谬误

164
00:04:34,406 --> 00:04:36,986
阿难始终预设心是一个物件

165
00:04:37,046 --> 00:04:39,226
可以被安放在某个位置上

166
00:04:39,445 --> 00:04:42,467
无论他说在内 在外还是在中间

167
00:04:42,606 --> 00:04:45,067
本质上都是在给心找坐标

168
00:04:45,445 --> 00:04:46,606
佛陀要破除的

169
00:04:46,806 --> 00:04:48,627
不是某个具体的坐标

170
00:04:48,685 --> 00:04:52,027
而是心需要坐标这个预设本身

171
00:04:52,315 --> 00:04:52,956
这个难题

172
00:04:53,315 --> 00:04:55,336
至今仍困扰着现代科学

173
00:04:55,594 --> 00:04:59,456
神经科学花了一百多年寻找意识在大脑中的定位

174
00:04:59,714 --> 00:05:01,396
有人说是前额叶皮层

175
00:05:01,834 --> 00:05:03,216
有人说是丘脑

176
00:05:03,315 --> 00:05:04,896
有人提出屏状核

177
00:05:05,034 --> 00:05:08,976
也有人认为意识是分布全脑的全局工作空间

178
00:05:09,154 --> 00:05:09,875
争论至今

179
00:05:10,274 --> 00:05:11,336
尚无定论

180
00:05:11,774 --> 00:05:14,555
这与阿难的七轮问答何其相似

181
00:05:14,813 --> 00:05:16,012
每找到一个位置

182
00:05:16,014 --> 00:05:18,115
就会被新的实验证据推翻

183
00:05:18,293 --> 00:05:19,892
并非找的位置不对

184
00:05:19,894 --> 00:05:23,394
而是意识是可以被定位的实体这一前提

185
00:05:23,413 --> 00:05:25,635
恐怕从一开始就错了

186
00:05:25,853 --> 00:05:28,995
楞严经 用七个问题拆解了这个前提

187
00:05:29,373 --> 00:05:30,175
今天的科学

188
00:05:30,574 --> 00:05:31,555
还在路上

189
00:05:32,159 --> 00:05:33,840
这是 楞严经 的第一把刀

190
00:05:34,438 --> 00:05:34,939
心

191
00:05:34,958 --> 00:05:37,140
不是一个可以被安放的对象

192
00:05:37,318 --> 00:05:39,380
但经文并未止步于此

193
00:05:39,398 --> 00:05:41,419
还有第二把更锋利的刀

194
00:05:41,876 --> 00:05:43,537
破完心在何处

195
00:05:43,676 --> 00:05:45,677
佛陀紧接着抛出另一个命题

196
00:05:46,196 --> 00:05:47,237
你所见的一切

197
00:05:47,516 --> 00:05:49,456
并非外界传送而来

198
00:05:49,475 --> 00:05:52,056
而是你自己的心识系统生成的

199
00:05:52,275 --> 00:05:54,657
经中称之为循业发现

200
00:05:55,035 --> 00:05:55,477
循业

201
00:05:55,835 --> 00:05:58,117
即顺着过往累积的业力习气

202
00:05:58,795 --> 00:05:59,237
发现

203
00:05:59,556 --> 00:06:01,155
不是找到了新事物

204
00:06:01,155 --> 00:06:03,657
而是当下的感知如此呈现

205
00:06:04,250 --> 00:06:05,512
讲件我自己的事

206
00:06:05,810 --> 00:06:06,611
某年冬夜

207
00:06:07,010 --> 00:06:08,632
我半夜起身倒水

208
00:06:08,731 --> 00:06:09,930
路过客厅时

209
00:06:09,930 --> 00:06:12,911
余光瞥见沙发旁地上有一团黑影

210
00:06:13,010 --> 00:06:13,851
浑身一激灵

211
00:06:14,130 --> 00:06:15,192
脚步顿住

212
00:06:15,331 --> 00:06:15,812
那一瞬

213
00:06:16,130 --> 00:06:18,471
大脑告诉我那是只大老鼠

214
00:06:18,531 --> 00:06:19,372
心跳加速

215
00:06:19,570 --> 00:06:20,291
后背发凉

216
00:06:20,611 --> 00:06:21,911
手微微发抖

217
00:06:22,091 --> 00:06:23,192
打开灯一看

218
00:06:23,291 --> 00:06:26,952
不过是女儿白天落在地上的黑色毛绒拖鞋

219
00:06:27,171 --> 00:06:28,411
老鼠从未存在

220
00:06:28,731 --> 00:06:30,209
恐惧却是真的

221
00:06:30,211 --> 00:06:31,872
心跳也是真的

222
00:06:32,253 --> 00:06:33,655
那只老鼠是谁放的

223
00:06:34,174 --> 00:06:35,155
不是拖鞋

224
00:06:35,253 --> 00:06:38,492
是我自己的心识系统在光线昏暗时

225
00:06:38,494 --> 00:06:42,035
调取过往经验数据库主动渲染出来的

226
00:06:42,174 --> 00:06:42,975
你仔细想想

227
00:06:43,253 --> 00:06:45,155
这种事你一定也经历过

228
00:06:45,453 --> 00:06:47,635
半夜的衣架变成了一个人影

229
00:06:47,773 --> 00:06:50,515
角落里的水管声变成了有人在走动

230
00:06:50,854 --> 00:06:51,374
每一次

231
00:06:51,693 --> 00:06:53,994
都是你的心识先交了答卷

232
00:06:54,133 --> 00:06:56,234
你的感官后来才去校对

233
00:06:56,562 --> 00:07:00,824
这正是现代认知科学预测编码理论所描述的过程

234
00:07:01,002 --> 00:07:03,783
大脑并非被动接收信号的摄像头

235
00:07:03,843 --> 00:07:05,343
而是一台预测引擎

236
00:07:05,523 --> 00:07:08,343
它先依据过往经验生成预期画面

237
00:07:08,483 --> 00:07:10,343
再用感官数据校验

238
00:07:10,723 --> 00:07:12,084
匹配则觉正常

239
00:07:12,442 --> 00:07:14,384
不匹配则产生误差

240
00:07:14,403 --> 00:07:15,904
进而微调模型

241
00:07:16,082 --> 00:07:17,204
关键在于顺序

242
00:07:17,642 --> 00:07:18,961
你看到的世界

243
00:07:18,963 --> 00:07:20,483
首先源于大脑的预测

244
00:07:20,762 --> 00:07:22,264
而非外界信号

245
00:07:22,483 --> 00:07:23,243
先有预测

246
00:07:23,562 --> 00:07:24,704
后有校验

247
00:07:25,256 --> 00:07:27,197
楞严经 说的便是此事

248
00:07:27,216 --> 00:07:28,757
只是换了种表述

249
00:07:29,096 --> 00:07:30,917
你所见的不是外境

250
00:07:30,975 --> 00:07:35,237
而是心识系统依循业力种子在当下投射的画面

251
00:07:35,495 --> 00:07:36,016
你的业

252
00:07:36,375 --> 00:07:37,697
就是先验模型

253
00:07:38,256 --> 00:07:38,697
六根

254
00:07:39,055 --> 00:07:40,857
是接收误差信号的通道

255
00:07:41,456 --> 00:07:43,357
此刻感知的整个世界

256
00:07:43,375 --> 00:07:46,237
皆是这套模型渲染出的现实版本

257
00:07:46,696 --> 00:07:48,976
此前讲唯识学时提过这个结构

258
00:07:49,456 --> 00:07:52,076
阿赖耶识的种子是模型参数

259
00:07:52,175 --> 00:07:54,596
第六意识是当下的推理进程

260
00:07:54,776 --> 00:07:59,636
末那识则是那个永远给结果盖上这是我印章的审核员

261
00:08:00,295 --> 00:08:01,937
楞严经 在此更进一步

262
00:08:02,256 --> 00:08:04,757
它不只是解释心识如何运作

263
00:08:04,776 --> 00:08:08,934
而是直指你看到的整个世界都是这套系统的输出

264
00:08:08,935 --> 00:08:09,956
而非输入

265
00:08:10,679 --> 00:08:11,520
这意味着什么

266
00:08:11,999 --> 00:08:14,179
意味着你跟你认识的每一个人

267
00:08:14,278 --> 00:08:16,699
可能生活在同一个物理世界里

268
00:08:16,799 --> 00:08:18,780
但感知到的完全不同

269
00:08:19,198 --> 00:08:21,699
一个从小怕狗的人走进公园

270
00:08:21,879 --> 00:08:25,340
第一眼看到的就是远处那条拴着绳子的狗

271
00:08:25,758 --> 00:08:28,379
一个园艺爱好者走进同一个公园

272
00:08:28,439 --> 00:08:31,900
第一眼看到的是花坛里新开的那丛月季

273
00:08:32,359 --> 00:08:33,699
世界是同一个

274
00:08:33,758 --> 00:08:36,459
但他们的心识根据各自的种子库

275
00:08:36,598 --> 00:08:38,860
渲染出来的画面完全不一样

276
00:08:39,198 --> 00:08:41,660
这就是循业发现的日常版本

277
00:08:41,919 --> 00:08:43,280
你以为你在看世界

278
00:08:43,598 --> 00:08:45,140
其实你在看自己

279
00:08:45,718 --> 00:08:46,488
不过

280
00:08:46,488 --> 00:08:49,549
楞严经 比预测编码多走了关键一步

281
00:08:49,647 --> 00:08:52,709
预测编码止步于大脑是预测引擎

282
00:08:52,808 --> 00:08:55,748
致力于让预测更精准 减少误差

283
00:08:55,808 --> 00:08:57,789
以此推动认知进步

284
00:08:58,007 --> 00:08:58,929
楞严经 却说

285
00:08:59,247 --> 00:09:00,069
还不够

286
00:09:00,247 --> 00:09:02,406
问题不在于预测准不准

287
00:09:02,407 --> 00:09:05,868
而在于你把预测的画面当成了真实世界

288
00:09:05,887 --> 00:09:08,949
把自己的投射当成了客观现实

289
00:09:09,047 --> 00:09:10,909
这才是无明的根源

290
00:09:11,947 --> 00:09:13,028
佛陀打了个比方

291
00:09:13,547 --> 00:09:15,048
有人眼生翳障

292
00:09:15,067 --> 00:09:16,249
夜里看灯火

293
00:09:16,268 --> 00:09:19,528
会看见灯焰外面套着一圈五色的光晕

294
00:09:19,748 --> 00:09:22,128
便以为那盏灯真的长了光晕

295
00:09:22,388 --> 00:09:23,148
旁人否认

296
00:09:23,388 --> 00:09:24,168
他不信

297
00:09:24,588 --> 00:09:25,069
佛陀说

298
00:09:25,427 --> 00:09:27,507
你每日所见的整个世界

299
00:09:27,508 --> 00:09:30,369
都是在眼有翳障的状态下看到的

300
00:09:30,468 --> 00:09:31,749
这翳障不在生理

301
00:09:31,907 --> 00:09:32,969
而在认知

302
00:09:33,067 --> 00:09:37,768
是心识系统带着无始以来的先验权重在渲染万象

303
00:09:38,108 --> 00:09:40,189
何时能见那盏灯的本来面目

304
00:09:40,588 --> 00:09:42,528
不是换一副更好的眼镜

305
00:09:42,547 --> 00:09:44,027
而是眼翳痊愈

306
00:09:44,027 --> 00:09:47,128
不再把自身的投射当作世界本身

307
00:09:48,025 --> 00:09:51,285
这便与上期讲的 大乘起信论 呼应上了

308
00:09:51,464 --> 00:09:54,886
起信论 说真如门是不生不灭的觉性

309
00:09:55,064 --> 00:09:57,925
生灭门是阿赖耶识的染净交织

310
00:09:58,265 --> 00:10:00,466
楞严经 在此补了更锋利的一刀

311
00:10:00,865 --> 00:10:02,886
你之所以在生灭门里打转

312
00:10:03,025 --> 00:10:04,886
不是因为外界太复杂

313
00:10:04,944 --> 00:10:09,606
而是从未怀疑过自己眼中的世界究竟从何而来

314
00:10:10,014 --> 00:10:12,235
你一直在找心在哪里

315
00:10:12,335 --> 00:10:12,895
佛陀说

316
00:10:13,215 --> 00:10:15,053
问题不在心在哪儿

317
00:10:15,055 --> 00:10:18,293
而在你预设了一个可以安放心的哪儿

318
00:10:18,294 --> 00:10:20,395
你一直在找真实的世界

319
00:10:20,414 --> 00:10:20,936
佛陀说

320
00:10:21,254 --> 00:10:23,115
问题不在世界真假

321
00:10:23,134 --> 00:10:25,916
而在你以为自己看到的就是世界

322
00:10:26,055 --> 00:10:27,395
两把刀合璧

323
00:10:27,414 --> 00:10:30,135
楞严经 上半部便完成了核心使命

324
00:10:30,534 --> 00:10:33,355
拆尽关于内与外的全部假设

325
00:10:33,534 --> 00:10:36,095
心不在内 不在外 不在中间

326
00:10:36,654 --> 00:10:38,653
世界非从外传入

327
00:10:38,654 --> 00:10:41,916
而是依循累积的种子在当下生成

328
00:10:42,015 --> 00:10:42,656
说到这儿

329
00:10:42,935 --> 00:10:44,736
想起评论区常有朋友问

330
00:10:45,214 --> 00:10:46,136
道理都懂了

331
00:10:46,334 --> 00:10:48,156
可念头就是停不下来

332
00:10:48,294 --> 00:10:49,094
闭上眼

333
00:10:49,094 --> 00:10:52,595
焦虑 创伤 悔恨的画面反复重放

334
00:10:52,775 --> 00:10:53,575
明知是假

335
00:10:53,775 --> 00:10:55,236
它却挥之不去

336
00:10:55,614 --> 00:10:58,355
其实七处征心已给出线索

337
00:10:58,574 --> 00:10:59,773
念头停不下来

338
00:10:59,775 --> 00:11:01,876
不是因为画面来自外界

339
00:11:02,015 --> 00:11:05,236
而是因为心识系统一直在循业发现

340
00:11:05,415 --> 00:11:07,715
依循旧种子自动渲染

341
00:11:08,607 --> 00:11:10,309
你以为在回忆过去

342
00:11:10,448 --> 00:11:13,828
实则是在当下重新创造了那个画面

343
00:11:14,367 --> 00:11:16,108
念头不是外来入侵者

344
00:11:16,168 --> 00:11:18,149
是你自己的系统在运行

345
00:11:18,448 --> 00:11:19,289
看清这一点

346
00:11:19,647 --> 00:11:21,348
不是为了强行止念

347
00:11:21,448 --> 00:11:23,948
而是在看见机器运转的那一刻

348
00:11:24,007 --> 00:11:26,588
你与它之间多出了一方空隙

349
00:11:26,808 --> 00:11:27,608
那方空隙

350
00:11:27,928 --> 00:11:29,429
正是修行的起点

351
00:11:29,673 --> 00:11:30,554
那么问题来了

352
00:11:30,833 --> 00:11:32,534
若心无处可寻

353
00:11:32,553 --> 00:11:34,115
若所见皆是投射

354
00:11:34,394 --> 00:11:35,794
究竟什么是真实的

355
00:11:36,193 --> 00:11:37,034
有没有一样东西

356
00:11:37,394 --> 00:11:38,274
是拆不掉的

357
00:11:38,833 --> 00:11:39,715
你有没有注意到

358
00:11:40,034 --> 00:11:41,592
当你真的安静下来

359
00:11:41,593 --> 00:11:43,894
不再忙着给心找位置的时候

360
00:11:43,994 --> 00:11:46,215
有一个东西是一直都在的

361
00:11:46,313 --> 00:11:47,673
它不需要位置

362
00:11:47,673 --> 00:11:50,735
但你此刻的每一个感知都离不开它

363
00:11:50,913 --> 00:11:52,232
它不需要定义

364
00:11:52,234 --> 00:11:54,934
但每一个定义都是从它出发的

365
00:11:55,193 --> 00:11:55,875
那是什么

366
00:11:56,394 --> 00:11:59,832
楞严经 下半部正是围绕这个问题展开的

367
00:11:59,833 --> 00:12:01,654
那便是下一期的内容了

368
00:12:01,885 --> 00:12:03,246
你觉得你的心在哪里

369
00:12:03,684 --> 00:12:05,045
今天听完七个答案

370
00:12:05,365 --> 00:12:06,905
全部被推翻了

371
00:12:07,084 --> 00:12:08,685
那你自己的答案是什么

372
00:12:09,245 --> 00:12:10,006
我很好奇

373
00:12:10,405 --> 00:12:12,705
想在评论区看到你的思考

374
00:12:13,125 --> 00:12:13,846
我是王利杰

375
00:12:14,125 --> 00:12:15,150
我们下期见